Maul vs. Bastila

Started by Master Vos12 pages

Wow, a lot of posts overnight. Anyway, if you do consider Force Powers Bastila would probably win, however I did mention that this was a lightsaber-only duel, but I'll cancel that.

Traya what Malak said served no purpose he was lying, he tried to comfort her later on as well by saying she couldn't lose because of the power of the Star Forge, and yeah he thought she might have had a small chance but didn't expect her to win. Bastila is not more powerful then Bandon.

Glentract you said that Bastila lead the assault team on Revan, you have no proof for this, if anything she kinda just came along for the ride and possible use of battle meditation, they didn't even want to take her at first. Let alone stadn she would lead the attack.

However Bastila was far from a bad Jedi, she walked into the heart of Revan his ship and saved his life, for some stupid reason. She trained with Revan for a long time on at least 4 planets and Dantooine. She learned the Dark Side for a week from Malak which means nothing but for much longer after that. In that week however she did learn force lightning, it could be that she learned it before. Storywise there is no evidence for that however. And as a Jedi it seems like a strange thing to learn, they aren't NJO Jedi after all. She may have learned a lot in those few weeks. She did kill a lot of Dark Jedi in her time and Maul would probably fall under her lightsaber in the end.

Bastila WAS being helped by a lot of Jedi though...and she never killed a Sith Lord...though, Bastila was a fool saving Revan...the Jedi didn't mind execution/letting an enemy die...Vodo Baas was more than willing to let Ulic be executed, the Jedi were very willing to let Naga Sadow die...not to mention they left Exar Kun to die

Well there were only two Sith Lords that she could have killed, Revan and Malak, both of them would pwn her in a fight and have... If you are talking about Sith Lord in general like high ranking or powerful Siths, then she could very well have.

She did fight Sith that were going after Revan, some of them would have been powerful. And in two years of leading the Sith Accademy she could have killed a few Sith Lords.. Besides Maul never killed a Sith Lord either...

Maul WAS a Sith Lord with Sidious as his boss...He killed Jedi masters, however

And since Revan was a lightside male, Bastila'd never have lead the Academy

Originally posted by Lightsnake
Bastila WAS being helped by a lot of Jedi though...and she never killed a Sith Lord...though, Bastila was a fool saving Revan...the Jedi didn't mind execution/letting an enemy die...Vodo Baas was more than willing to let Ulic be executed, the Jedi were very willing to let Naga Sadow die...not to mention they left Exar Kun to die

She killed that man on Revans flagship and considering Revans power, I am sure he doesn't have noobs guarding him personally.

Originally posted by Lightsnake
Maul WAS a Sith Lord with Sidious as his boss...He killed Jedi masters, however

And since Revan was a lightside male, Bastila'd never have lead the Academy

Any proof that Revan was a lightside male? I want an official statement, not some quote by random dude 'x'. Don't quote a site either, give me a link to the actual, official, site.

Maul killed 1 Jedi Master. Bastila has killed dozens of Sith Knights.

I already linked Fishy. Want Leland Chee's statement on it?

And ONE Jedi master? He killed quite a few more than one.

http://forums.starwars.com/thread.jspa?threadID=222689&start=615#12367041

From Leland Chee. on the SW forums. Or check out the databank

How is anyone supposed to know if that really is Leland Chee?

Well, gee, it's only under his bio, his information would have to be given and he'd have to be approved on the official Star Wars site...And since he's been a member for near six years....well, he'd be guilty of libel and fraud if he lied

Actually, Maul did kill one Jedi Master. He killed several other Bounty Hunters and other Thugs but he only killed a single Jedi Master.

He killed....two Twi'lek masters that we saw. one was the first victim of his double sided saber...he killed other Jedi on some other worlds, too, and a Nightsister.

Originally posted by Lightsnake
He killed....two Twi'lek masters that we saw. one was the first victim of his double sided saber...he killed other Jedi on some other worlds, too, and a Nightsister.

Nightsisters are nothing special as they spent large amounts of time to generate their spells and lacked the ability to use force attacks on the go.

Maul took out Qui-gon. Bondara died from the speeder explosion and Darsha(a padawan) also blew herself up. Names for these other guys, I've never heard of them.

Originally posted by Lightsnake
Well, gee, it's only under his bio, his information would have to be given and he'd have to be approved on the official Star Wars site...And since he's been a member for near six years....well, he'd be guilty of libel and fraud if he lied

SS has been around that long.

SS was threatened with legal action if he continued to claim he worked for LF. Needless to say he stopped. And does SS frequent SW.com?

And Maul killed the other twi'lek in the story 'Nameless' and he is mentioned to have kileld others in Shadow Hunter. He yearns for a true test of skill soon

And Bondara was getting destroyed by Maul and tried to take Maul with him

No, on SS's site it still says he is emplyed by GL, I just checked. It's under the About Supershadow spage.

Hm, indeed....I'll have to post that on SW.com and see if action's taken, since that's libel. As for Leland, though....he's on SW.com, which SS noticeably doesn't visit

Originally posted by Lightsnake
He killed....two Twi'lek masters that we saw. one was the first victim of his double sided saber...he killed other Jedi on some other worlds, too, and a Nightsister.

As I said before, Quinlan Vos took out at least nine of them alone. He was just a Knight.

Nightsisters are useless.

Infinity's End, you mean? Mighella wasn't part of Zalem's crew. Nightsisters gave Luke some issues....ok, albeit, he was only partly trained and massively outnumbered....

Bastila also survived throughout her lifetime, most likely. After ravaging at least hundreds of thugs, Sith Knights, Dark Jedi, Assassins, Etc etc...

She fought Revan once and stalemated with him at the Unknown beach planet. She also killed one of Revans bodyguards and she wasn't killed by no Padawan.