The Battle of LOTR!

Started by Maikahyandowen17 pages

I vote Isildur

Again difficult. Isildur killed Sauron.. OK OK.. destroyed part of him.. but he fell to the power of the ring. Imrahil.. well hes a good fighter.
OK.. despite the fact he fell to the power of the ring and was corrupted and DIED... Isildur.

Also because hes related to Aragorn.. tee hee

Boromir, the captain of Gondor

vs

Witch King of Angmar

is that a suggestion or what? only I, or in my absence, will someone make a new match.

At the moment Isildur is wiining 3-0. I will be posting a new one tmorow morning

Isildur wins!

Match 1
Round 16

Ghan-buri-Ghan

VS

Legolas

VOTE NOW!

Legolas all the way!

Legolas

Legolas.... i mean come on.. there is no point in arguing it.

Really? I always base my descicons on book, so i would say Book Legolas would lose but Film Legolas may win?! So i go with Ghan, but Legolas wins 3-1!

Match 1
Round 17

Goldberry

VS

Glorfindel

Glorfindel!

Goldberry isn't really a warrior. So i vote glorfindel.

[Edit.]

Originally posted by RvB]Tucker
Goldberry isn't really a warrior. So i vote glorfindel.

No she is not, but Goldberry is a mysterious being whose place in Tolkien's mythology isn't easy to establish. She seems to be some kind of river-spirit, though some have conjectured that both Tom and Goldberry belong to the order of the Maiar. So i vote Goldberry🙂

Voting will close tomorow🙂

Originally posted by DanielLB
No she is not, but Goldberry is a mysterious being whose place in Tolkien's mythology isn't easy to establish. She seems to be some kind of river-spirit, though some have conjectured that both Tom and Goldberry belong to the order of the Maiar. So i vote Goldberry🙂

Voting will close tomorow🙂

Yes as you said what she is isn't really established. So it doesn't count uif she wins cause gor all we know she could be just a harmless sirit. She can have absolutly no lethal owers at all.

Goldberry wins definitely..........

its 2-2 so both will go into the next match. Ill post another round later today🙂

Please vote for both matches🙂
If you dont no enough about the person reaserch before you vote🙂

Round 1
Match 18

Elros

VS

Elendil

Match 19

Cirdan

VS

Denethor II

Match 18: Elros
Match 19: Cirdan

Elros beats Elendil into a pulp and Cirdan beats Denethor so badly it just isn't funny.

I voted for Cirdan and Elros too