My Idea of what the Marvel vs DC comics should have been

In this line up the Fans choose just like in the real Marvel vs DC comic books

This is what Marvel vs DC should have been.
Gladiator vs Superman
Thor vs Wonder Woman.
Magneto vs Captain Marvel
Genis-Vell vs Green Lantern
Captain America vs Batman
Sub Mariner vs Aquaman
Thanos vs Darkseid.
Overmind vs Martian Manhunter.
Morg at full power vs Doomsday.
Classic Juggernaut vs Lobo
Savage Hulk vs Solomon Grundy
Iron Man vs Steel
Flash vs Makkari
Wolverine vs Deathstroke
Luke Cage vs Bane
Mephisto vs Dr Fate
Silver Sufer vs Firestorm
Robin vs Howard the Duck 😆
Gambit vs Green Arrow
Orion vs Beta Ray Bill

Magneto and Captain Marvel have nothing in common. And you know very little if you're writing off Robin (a.k.a. Batman Lite) like that.

No I was just kidding let see Robin vs Bucky.

Howard the Duck-Powers/Abilities: Though he rarely uses it, Howard is the master of a rare martial art known as Quak Fu, which enabled him to take out a gang of four adult men, and grab a hurled knife or spinning nunchaku out of mid-air. It might be that the abilities were briefly granted to him in a quasi-mystical matter, after which they swiftly faded.

Winners in caps. All of these battles assume a neutral battleground (no influence from sales, popularity, iconic status, or jobber auras).

Gladiator vs SUPERMAN
THOR vs Wonder Woman
Magneto vs CAPTAIN MARVEL
Genis-Vell vs GREEN LANTERN
CAPTAIN AMERICA vs Batman
SUB-MARINER vs Aquaman
Thanos vs DARKSEID
OVERMIND vs Martian Manhunter.
Morg at full power vs DOOMSDAY
JUGGERNAUT vs Lobo
HULK vs Solomon Grundy
IRON MAN vs Steel
Makkari vs FLASH
Wolverine vs DEATHSTROKE
CAGE vs Bane
Mephisto vs DR FATE
SILVER SURFER vs Firestorm
BUCKY vs Robin
GAMBIT vs Green Arrow
Beta Ray Bill vs ORION

Marvel takes it 11-9

A couple matches I'd put down if I were writing my own...

Batman vs Black Panther (Batman)
Superman vs Sentry (Draw possibly, or Superman)
Wonder Woman vs Thor (Thor)
Grundy vs Hulk (Hulk)
Aquaman vs Namor (Aquaman)
Doomsday vs Juggernaut (No idea)
Ion vs Silver Surfer (Ion)
Darkseid vs Galactus (Not sure)
Lobo vs Apocalypse (Not sure)
Martian Manhunter vs Magneto (Magneto)
Dr. Fate vs Dr. Strange (Dr. Strange)
Green Arrow vs Hawkeye (Let the fans decide that one)
Flash vs Quicksilver (Flash..duh)
Copperhead vs Lizard (Lizard)
Catwoman vs Black Cat (Catwoman)
Iron Man vs Steel (Iron Man)
Parallax vs Thanos (No clue)

People I would throw in but I couldn't think of a matchup right now:
Cyclops, Wolverine, Spider-Man, Fantastic 4, Colossus, Nightcrawler, Gambit, Bullseye, Nightwing, Robin, Captain America, uh....

huh ??

Really peeved me off when in that book the juggernaut gets knocked down with one punch from superman. REALLY P*%$#& me off!

I really think Doomsday would lose to a Full powered Morg easy he just to to powerful for Doomsday.

Originally posted by JohnR
Winners in caps. All of these battles assume a neutral battleground (no influence from sales, popularity, iconic status, or jobber auras).

Gladiator vs SUPERMAN
Genis-Vell vs GREEN LANTERN
Thanos vs DARKSEID
Marvel takes it 11-9

Originally posted by outarddwarf
Really peeved me off when in that book the juggernaut gets knocked down with one punch from superman. REALLY P*%$#& me off!

Originally posted by golem370
Mephisto vs Dr Fate

To make it like a Good vs Evil Mephisto is no joke ether though.

Mephisto
Intelligence: Immeasurable (10/10)
Strength: Unrevealed (can be magically augmented to potentially incalculable levels)
Speed: Enhanced Human (5/10)
Stamina: Godlike (9/10)
Durability: Godlike (13/14)
Agility: Enhanced Human (5/7)
Reflexes: Enhanced Human (5/7)
Fighting Skills: Unrevealed; Mephisto does not engage in physical combat
Special Skills/Abilities: Vast knowledge of magical lore
Superhuman physical powers: Aside from the above listed attributes, immortality; vast inherent supernatural power and virtually unlimited ability to manipulate magical energies for virtually any purpose
Superhuman Mental Powers: Unrevealed; see above

Originally posted by outarddwarf
Really peeved me off when in that book the juggernaut gets knocked down with one punch from superman. REALLY P*%$#& me off!

I enjoyed it! 🙂

😆 All Supes fanboys enjoyed it

Juggernaut can be knocked down, when he's not expecting it.
It's the next punch that's the problem - for the other person. 😉

bump

Bump one more time

Quasar - Kyle Rayner
Black Panther - Batman
Sentry - Superman
Odin - Highfather
Deadpool - Deathstroke
Makkari - Wally West
Depowered Tyrant - True Darkseid
Thanos - Darkseid (avatar)
Thor - Captain Marvel
Gladiator - Wonder Woman

Keep in mind Depowered Tyrant had nigh-infinite power and squatted 5 herald level's like flies, Thanos was only able to fight him in because he used one Tyrants own enchantments tapping into his power, otherwise Thanos would go down in one hit.

I think the Superman vs Gladiator would be the greatest fight because Although Gladiator has the confidence weakness I believe in this fight he would be extremely inclined to win. Gladiator is not just fighting for himself but also to keep The Shi'ar Empire from being erased from exsistance

Originally posted by Thanos_THOTU
Quasar - Kyle Rayner
Black Panther - Batman
Sentry - Superman
Odin - Highfather
Deadpool - Deathstroke
Makkari - Wally West
Depowered Tyrant - True Darkseid
Thanos - Darkseid (avatar)
Thor - Captain Marvel
Gladiator - Wonder Woman

Keep in mind Depowered Tyrant had nigh-infinite power and squatted 5 herald level's like flies, Thanos was only able to fight him in because he used one Tyrants own enchantments tapping into his power, otherwise Thanos would go down in one hit.

Orb or not He would have done just as well

Allthough he said he would fall without it, Thanos was even losing with it.
Darkseid's true form has nigh-infinite power, cube beings, celestial's and so forth has infinite power, that's why I put him with Depowered Tyrant.