Luminara Unduli versus General Grievous

Started by DARTH POWER4 pages
Originally posted by SIDIOUS 66
That argument came from the same exact person who said Sidious was struggling against Maul and Savage. 😆

You still crying about an angry Maul challenging Sidious all on his own 😂

Or you looking for the hidden meaning behind Filoni outright telling us that Opress alone did better than your 3 "celebrated" stooges 😆

Or about Obi-Wan's smackdown of the Brothers being easily as impressive as Sidious's 💃

Originally posted by Mizukage Yoda
I am pretty confused about Grievous' place in all this. I mean the guy was stalemeating Mace ****ing Windu in sabers during LOE. And yet Ventress cut his arm off quicker than even Mace could. Smells like BS to me.

That was before the Lucasian edict that Grievous be a moderately talented fighter. Mace or Yoda would trash Grievous.

Originally posted by DARTH POWER
You still crying about an angry Maul challenging Sidious all on his own 😂

Actually, I'm more mad about Bariss being able to compete with Sidious. And not just in sabers, but in an all-out.

Originally posted by SIDIOUS 66
Actually, I'm more mad about Bariss being able to compete with Sidious. And not just in sabers, but in an all-out.

Compete? That's pretty generous... to the Dark Lord. 😬

In other words, Barriss curbstomped Ahsoka, who in turn held her own against a four-blade-wielding Grievous, who in turn defeated season 5!Obi-Wan with only two blades. (That means Grievous was twice as powerful when he fought Ahsoka vis a vis Obi-Wan.) The same Obi-Wan who annihilated Savage and Maul combined and can compete with Sidious.

Barriss currently sits atop the mountain on a gilded throne.

Originally posted by The_Tempest
Compete? That's pretty generous... to the Dark Lord. 😬

In other words, Barriss curbstomped Ahsoka, who in turn held her own against a four-blade-wielding Grievous, who in turn defeated season 5!Obi-Wan with only two blades. (That means Grievous was twice as powerful when he fought Ahsoka vis a vis Obi-Wan.) The same Obi-Wan who annihilated Savage and Maul combined and can compete with Sidious.

Barriss currently sits atop the mountain on a gilded throne.

Well Barriss needed two sabers to fight Ahsoka otherwise it might have been a tie.

Perhaps Sidious would be able to compete with Barriss if she had only one lightsaber and he had two. Maybe?

Originally posted by SIDIOUS 66
Well Barriss needed two sabers to fight Ahsoka otherwise it might have been a tie.

Perhaps Sidious would be able to compete with Barriss if she had only one lightsaber and he had two. Maybe?

I think the idea that adding more lightsabers would significantly increase one's fighting potential is ridiculous. Logically, if more lightsabers equals more power, than every jedi would take a second lightsaber to make themselves more effective. Besides, Obiwan's tooling of 4-armed Grievous in ROTS clearly shows that spamming lighstabers is overrated.

Originally posted by SIDIOUS 66
Actually, I'm more mad about Bariss being able to compete with Sidious. And not just in sabers, but in an all-out.

???

Yeah because sucker punching Ventress is really comparable to challenging Sidious.

Originally posted by Vensai
I think the idea that adding more lightsabers would significantly increase one's fighting potential is ridiculous. Logically, if more lightsabers equals more power, than every jedi would take a second lightsaber to make themselves more effective. Besides, Obiwan's tooling of 4-armed Grievous in ROTS clearly shows that spamming lighstabers is overrated.

They're making fun of me. But I don't even say "The more Sabers the more Uber."

The only thing I've suggested is 2 Sabers is better suited to take on 2 opponents. Especially if they're surrounding you from opposite sides. It was clearly useful to Obi-Wan in his situation against the Brothers. But NOT the all and end all.

As for one on one's it depends on what the person's style is. I'd say Ashoka was at a disadvantage against Barris because it's her usual style to wield a Shoto with her Lightsaber.

Just like Ventress was probably at a disadvantage when she fought Opress for the same reason.

But I've never said or even suggested that when someone picks up a second Saber they're automatically twice as powerful. The main advantage would be in being able to switch styles to see what works best against your opponent. Kasim switched from 1 Saber to Jar Kai and as a result began defeating Bane.

There's a lot of different factors to fights. The number of weapons would be A factor. I've never suggested it's everything.

Grievous takes it.