Iceman vs. Superman was probably the most intelligent, rational, fanboyless thread ever. EVER. In the history of everness. Fun stuff, though it got pretty complicated. WAY too much science.
WW vs. Superman, solely because I enjoy backing the underdog. WW 6/10. Whatcha gon' do?
Wolverine vs. Spiderman probably ended up as the closest thing to formal debate we've had here. Hilarious, if only for the sheer number of ad hominems and strawmans called out. It was more intelligent than most people gave it credit for. Though leaving for an hour and coming back to read through 2 hours worth of posts ended up being annoying.
I personally enjoyed Cap vs. Batman... If only because I was God for a day or two. Coherent debate within fanboy madness.
Anything good with Thanos and Silver Surfer is fun too. Because they never lose, no matter how the thread starter tries... (vs. Batman is just stupid, but all of the Supermannish people vs. Thanos craze was cool)
have to say I like the Iceman vs Superman, though it was funny a triple team on Whirly with me, Ill and Demi.... or as Dizzle said ,"Iceman vs. Superman was probably the most intelligent, rational, fanboyless thread ever. EVER. In the history of everness. Fun stuff, though it got pretty complicated. WAY too much science."