Nice scans sado, love to see that shit, though its not considered cannon its still great to see punisher own these supers. This was the comic that reintroduced me to the glorious world of Punisher helmed by the great Garth Ennis. Most of his arc's and one shots in MAX are some of the greatest Punisher stories ever. Sadly he will be leaving soon, hope this next writer can follow Ennis's lead.
Originally posted by jgiant
Nice scans sado, love to see that shit, though its not considered cannon its still great to see punisher own these supers. This was the comic that reintroduced me to the glorious world of Punisher helmed by the great Garth Ennis. Most of his arc's and one shots in MAX are some of the greatest Punisher stories ever. Sadly he will be leaving soon, hope this next writer can follow Ennis's lead.
Its not considered canon? 😕
Originally posted by AlmightyKfishThat was Marvel Knights...and its not considered cannon because...well because it just isn't...spiderman didn't have spidersense, he would have known those mines were fake, and wolverine should have heard or been alerted to frank shooting that rocket launcher.
No Punisher Max is a non canon story.
Originally posted by jgiant
...spiderman didn't have spidersense, he would have known those mines were fake,
Yes he did and he would not have known that the mines were fake. You know that Spiderman senses warn him a split second before he triggers a bomb right? Spiderman thought that the reason why his spider sense didn't give him a warning was because he hadn't triggered the bombs.
There is an example of MJ about to open a booby trapped door. Spiderman senses warn him just as the door is about to explode. How would Spiderman react if he thought the door was already booby trapped but it wasn't? He wouldnt have even touched it in the first place and he would not need his spidersense to warn him, but the only way to clarify this with his spidersense would be to open the door but Spiderman would not do this because he already thinks that the door is booby trapped. Its the samething with the mines. Spiderman thought he hadn't triggered the bombs yet and hence his spidersense did not warn him.
Originally posted by jgiant
and wolverine should have heard or been alerted to frank shooting that rocket launcher.
1. Wolverine was distracted.
2. The missle launcher was far away.
3. A missle travels fatser than a bullet.
4. You know the number of times Wolverine been shot while being distracted and by ordinary people including the Punisher?
Originally posted by Phantom Zoneall ligit arguments, hell i believe the events are possible...im just saying why people would argue its not cannon, that and its Marvel Knights and not just Marvel.
Yes he did and he would not have known that the mines were fake. You know that Spiderman senses warn him a split second before he triggers a bomb right? Spiderman thought that the reason why his spider sense didn't give him a warning was because he hadn't triggered the bombs.There is an example of MJ about to open a booby trapped door. Spiderman senses warn him just as the door is about to explode. How would Spiderman react if he thought the door was already booby trapped but it wasn't? He wouldnt have even touched it in the first place and he would not need his spidersense to warn him, but the only way to clarify this with his spidersense would be to open the door but Spiderman would not do this because he already thinks that the door is booby trapped. Its the samething with the mines. Spiderman thought he hadn't triggered the bombs yet and hence his spidersense did not warn him.
1. Wolverine was distracted.
2. The missle launcher was far away.
3. A missle travels fatser than a bullet.
4. You know the number of times Wolverine been shot while being distracted and by ordinary people including the Punisher?
Originally posted by jgiant
all ligit arguments, hell i believe the events are possible...im just saying why people would argue its not cannon, that and its Marvel Knights and not just Marvel.
I think marvel knights is canon. Didn't Punsiher run over Wolverine and didn't Wolverine mention it in a non marvel knights issue?
Originally posted by Phantom ZoneYea, its a complicated issue, since it was two writers taking jabs at one another...ennis taking jabs at superhuman hero's of marvel and wolverines writer at the time taking a jab at ennis punisher for what he did. Most don't consider it cannon, and if i recall someone even said that marvel said it wasn't cannon, don't know how true that is.
I think marvel knights is canon. Didn't Punsiher run over Wolverine and didn't Wolverine mention it in a non marvel knights issue?
Originally posted by jgiant
Yea, its a complicated issue, since it was two writers taking jabs at one another...ennis taking jabs at superhuman hero's of marvel and wolverines writer at the time taking a jab at ennis punisher for what he did. Most don't consider it cannon, and if i recall someone even said that marvel said it wasn't cannon, don't know how true that is.
I think i've had this discussion before and nobody has given any evidence that its not canon. I don't know who these people are who don't think its non-canon.
http://www.mania.com/marvel-knights-10-years-ww-philly_article_58301.html
Na I think its canon this article even mentions how marvel knights titles have affected mainstream marvel it has to be canon.
The events in Marvel Knights comics have gone on to have a wider impact in the rest of the Marvel Universe. Peter David’s Madrox limited series spawned the current hit series X-Factor and both Grant Morrison’s Marvel Boy and Paul Jenkins’ Sentry regularly appear in the Avengers line of comics, both promising to play a big role in the mega-event Secret Invasion!
Again even if it is writers taking a jab at each other if an event in a marvel knight comic is mentioned in a mainstream that makes it canon...yeah this is confusing.
Sentry shoving/hitting Frank far away with a fwummmp sound and threw a window. Frank kinda sore but is still keeps ticking, shows some dur...
http://img61.imageshack.us/img61/4153/punisher1015es2.jpg
http://img230.imageshack.us/img230/5403/punisher1016vh7.jpg
