Originally posted by llagrok
Quanchi's under the impression that if someone else with the same power as you performs poorly, you're bound to as well.If Thor beat the weakest and most inexperienced Green Lantern, Quanchi would automatically assume that he would beat Kyle or Hal as well.
Inexperienced Newbie Lantern > Spiderman > Masterson Thor = Thor.
😖hifty:.
Originally posted by Nike
Couldn't the same be said for both characters regarding each others win loss record?Now this is what you'll have to prove.
Are you under the impression that I think Kyle would win 10/10 over Thor? Go back and read my exchange with Phenomenal, excuse me, PhenomenOL and you'll see clearly why I said that.
Originally posted by OneDumbG0
Classic Thor gets no respect.Thor 7/10, classic or otherwise.
Originally posted by ValidusAre you insinuating that the measure of respect he gets validates his worth in a hypothetical fight? So only three people here support him and that means he gets punked by Green Lantern? Because you've got more than half the KMC'ers saying that Thor beats Superman in that thread. I hope you're not extending yourself to ABC logic now and saying that Kyle curbstomps Superman in spite if he easily beats Thor?
You've got two creatures in here claiming Thor beats Kyle 10/10. I'd say thats far more respect than he deserves.
No. I didn't think so. Now instead of wasting everyone's time by putting words into your mouth, please explain why Thor sucks so much in this fight, in your opinion?
Originally posted by SoljerKinda too soon to speculate that he used the Odinforce to rebuild it. He uses Mjolnir to recreate Asgard on-panel and nowhere is Odinforce mentioned. But what is mentioned is, "Where there is Thor, there is Asgard." Plus, he's keeping it afloat perpetually. But yeah, too soon to tell. I wonder how Straczynski's gonna play Thor's return.
Isn't Kyle currently Parallax?And, correct me if I'm wrong, but current Thor hasn't really done much of anything beyond rebuild asgard - and who knows how much of the odinforce it took to rebuild it?
Originally posted by OneDumbG0
Kinda too soon to speculate that he used the Odinforce to rebuild it. He uses Mjolnir to recreate Asgard on-panel and nowhere is Odinforce mentioned. But what is mentioned is, "Where there is Thor, there is Asgard." Plus, he's keeping it afloat perpetually. But yeah, too soon to tell. I wonder how Straczynski's gonna play Thor's return.
I agree entirely - even on the fact that we don't know whether Thor used the odin force or not to recreate asgard.
What we DO know is...pretty much nothing. Save the fact that he's going to fight Iron Man. 😬. And, even if he STOMPS Iron Man, that hardly puts him on level with Kyle.
We really need to wait for quite a few more issues before we start gauging current Thor - however, it's worth noting that he'd have QUITE a match on his hands, no matter how powerful he's written. A Parallax possessed Ion is nothing to underestimate.
Meh.
Classic is certainly in Kyle's favor, however.
In my most humble of opinions.
Originally posted by OneDumbG0
Are you insinuating that the measure of respect he gets validates his worth in a hypothetical fight? So only three people here support him and that means he gets punked by Green Lantern? Because you've got more than half the KMC'ers saying that Thor beats Superman in that thread. I hope you're not extending yourself to ABC logic now and saying that Kyle curbstomps Superman in spite if he easily beats Thor?No. I didn't think so. Now instead of wasting everyone's time by putting words into your mouth, please explain why Thor sucks so much in this fight, in your opinion?
Originally posted by ValidusErr. I was just commenting on how your original response to my post was dangerously close to an appeal to the majority. And that an appeal to the majority is about as fallacious as ABC logic. And that an appeal to the majority + ABC logic gleaned from these forums would end up with the result that:
What exactly caused you to go off on this tangent? Superman? ABC logic? Spite threads? Putting words in my mouth?
Kyle > handily owns > Thor
Thor > beats for a majority > Superman
Kyle > curbstomps (who made this spite thread?!) > Superman
And that is clearly a result that we obviously both don't agree with. So having cleared that up, why does Classic Thor not really deserve respect? Or was that sort of a humorous aside since you seem to state that it could be 6/10 either way...
Originally posted by OneDumbG0
And that is clearly a result that we obviously both don't agree with. So having cleared that up, why does Classic Thor not really deserve respect? Or was that sort of a humorous aside since you seem to state that it could be 6/10 either way...
Originally posted by nvrbeenwthagirl
Kyle wins. 8/10. His subconcious mind created Oblivion. He created a daxamite with a Gl Ring subconciously. He made a free thinking JLA. And GL corps in one fight. He held a big bang. Thor is good. And yes I think Kyle beats Superman, WW, and most any other top tier.
You forgot to mention that some of the Lanterns he created were also speed-force-manipulators.