ROTS Obi Wan vs TPM Qui Gon Jin

Setting is Mustafar

I assume that people believe that Obi Wan wins, but considering Qui Gon was Jedi Master, and that Obi Wan beat Maul out of pure rage, im sure it would be a close match, and neither am i sure who would win.

Obi-Wan wins, and if anyone here'd say Qui-Gon'd win it'd probably be me. But there's no way.

Obi-Wan wins. Believe me, I am a Qui-Gon fan, but there is just no way he could win.

wanst qui gonn a hero from the hyperspace wars?

well anyway qui gon had more experience than obi wan
id like to see some proof, proving that obi wan would surely take the win, and qui gon would surely lose

Qui-gon had more training, not more experince. There is a difference.

i thought he was a hyperspace war-hero, alongside plo koon

Yeah, but the Clone Wars were much worse. Also, Obi-Wan has faced Sith.

Originally posted by Wesker
Also, Obi-Wan has faced Sith.

Qui Gon didn't exactly live through that, did he?

qui gon had a longer beard

Yeah, but Obi-Wan looks like Jesus with his hood up.

Originally posted by Wesker
Qui Gon didn't exactly live through that, did he?

yess, but qui gon was quite the pastor

Ah, you're right. Replace that with beat. Obi-Wan has actually beat two Sith, and duelled Dooku twice. Plus he's fought Ventress and others before, too.

what other sith did obi wan beat?

Obi takes this. His defenseare to much for Qui-Gon to penetrate. He'd tire out the way he did against Maul and ultimately lose

qui-gon gets raped...... during rots obiwans skills far superiored any jedi council members save mace , yoda and qui-gon could not compete with that!........sorry qui its the truth

Originally posted by vpokdekjyafmidp
what other sith did obi wan beat?

Maul and Vader.

oh yea, well i didnt really consider vader a sith just yet, just a fallen jedi, but he still won nonetheless