Odan Urr vs Freedon Nadd

Takes place on Tatooine.

Freedon Nadd's power is difficult to quantify, but I'm pretty sure he'd take Odan. Odan's no slouch, given his experience in the Great Hyperspace War, however.

Give it to Nadd, though.

Nadd.

Errr? Nadd should take this with similar difficulty to Kun at worst. He's instakilled before.

Originally posted by Illustrious
Errr? Nadd should take this with similar difficulty to Kun at worst. He's instakilled before.

Indeed. Why the hell was I qualifying it?

Nadd takes it.

Odan was very old by the time Exar killed him...

What if we are talking about the same Odan who fought against the armies of Naga Sadow?

Odan was more of a scholar than a fighter though so it wouldn't be a fair fight.

Indeed, Odan didn't really like fighting. He did do it, but he didn't like it. He isn't a great fighter at all, he's a great scholar. He build Osus that was his dream, thats what he does.

Nadd would probably take him out relatively easy...

That doesn't mean he wasn't powerful.

No he could have been powerful compared to others, but he couldn't have been great. He may have had the talent, but if he didn't have the wish to expand on it and become great with it, well then its simply not going to be enough.

That and the fact that Kun tooled him and Nadd from what we know is very powerful perhaps even more powerful then Kun is... Well I wouldn't give Odan much of a chance.

Your right guy with storm trooper as avatar. I just read the tales of the sith + fall of the sith empire, and I wanted to know how Odan Urr ranks up with all the Jedi. Could he defeat Yoda? How about Windu? Even Revan?

No. Odan Urr is a scholar and his knowledge might rank above any other Jedi/Sith but he isn't a fighter, nor does he want to fight.

Ah, thank you ttdd. Odan seemed like a likeable Jedi anyways, since he is THE Jedi *dork/geek* ("I prefer to read history instead of make it" 😉 )

His premonitions found the ancient sith empire so he is a very powerful jedi master.. Just a pussy.

Jesus...

Is there any special reason you people have seen fit to degrade Odan-Urr?

Odan was very old by the time Exar killed him...

And that doesn't mean shit. Nothing in the narration says he died of old age. On-panel evidence shows he was perfectly capable of fighting Kun (or, at least, trying to fight him. Kun was too strong).

Odan was more of a scholar than a fighter though so it wouldn't be a fair fight.

He isn't a great fighter at all, he's a great scholar. He build Osus that was his dream, thats what he does.

but he couldn't have been great. He may have had the talent, but if he didn't have the wish to expand on it and become great with it, well then its simply not going to be enough.

No. Odan Urr is a scholar and his knowledge might rank above any other Jedi/Sith but he isn't a fighter, nor does he want to fight.

His premonitions found the ancient sith empire so he is a very powerful jedi master.. Just a pussy.

Bullshit. Shown here is proof he fought in the Hyperspace war beyond the events portrayed in FotSE:

He has personal combat experience against the ancient Sith, became proficient in blocking them from the Force, and helped the rest of the Jedi and Republic "hunt the Sith into extinction."

He is not a "pussy." Just because he doesn't like to fight doesn't mean he can't. To say that is ridiculous. Do you think Yoda liked to fight?

Nadd will take him down, but I'm not going to let that mudslinging crap go by unanswered. Odan's a damned powerful Jedi.

You know, there are advantages to being a scholar. For one, Odan would have a greater knowledge of force powers because he has studied it so much. His lightsaber skill might be lacking, but all that time meditating and stuff would certainly help him.

Originally posted by tdtd
Nadd.

Originally posted by IKC
Jesus...

Is there any special reason you people have seen fit to degrade Odan-Urr?

And that doesn't mean shit. Nothing in the narration says he died of old age. On-panel evidence shows he was perfectly capable of fighting Kun (or, at least, trying to fight him. Kun was too strong).

Bullshit. Shown here is proof he fought in the Hyperspace war beyond the events portrayed in FotSE:

He has personal combat experience against the ancient Sith, became proficient in blocking them from the Force, and helped the rest of the Jedi and Republic "hunt the Sith into extinction."

He is not a "pussy." Just because he doesn't like to fight doesn't mean he can't. To say that is ridiculous. Do you think Yoda liked to fight?

Nadd will take him down, but I'm not going to let that mudslinging crap go by unanswered. Odan's a damned powerful Jedi.

All very nice, but the Sith its most powerful people were alraedy destroyed after Sadow returned, Kressh died. Many Dark Lords were killed immediately by there Massassi friends... The other Sith are never even expanded upon, he's not weak he isn't great either. There is no reason to assume that he became really powerful, his force techniques however are good, probably.. And he would probably be able to stand up even to the greatest with force powers, but he's a Jedi... Thats not going to make him kill people.

Actually, based on Odan-Urr's personal code, he's quite willing to kill people and more importantly, to die himself. Thus, he might have a better chance against Freedon Nadd than most Jedi, however, he will also eventually fall.

Would he be able to rank up with Vodo.