ANH Luke vs. TPM Anakin

luke has a lightsaber, anakin has a blaster pistol, settingis in that big arena on genoesis, with thousands of cheering fans.

i think anakin would win

you honestly think a whiny kid would beat a whiny teenager. granted you gave him the blaster, but just cause luke can't deflect yet doesn't mean he's dumb enough to just stand there.

I give it to luke by a power converter.

well anakin was very smart for his age, and i tihnk would know what to do, and when, and of course weild a gun.
while on the other hand, luke is a stupid farmboy who has the amazing ability to not know what do do, and cut his own head off.

Not know what to do??? what are you talking about?

...

Anakin: *Stares blankly at the blaster*
Luke: AHHHHHHHHH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! WTF, I'M GONNA FREAKING KILL YOU!!!!!!!!!!! AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH!!!!!!!!!!
Anakin: *Scratches head*
Luke: GAAHHHHHHHHHHHH!!!!! *Slashes the air*
Anakin: *Hits trigger on accident and shoots Luke's leg.*
Luke: Gah! Damn it, you ****ing bastard!!!!!!
Anakin: Wha? Wait, I hit him! Yippee!!!
Luke: *Head explodes*

So, now you know that Anakin wins.

well he did make his own robot at that age, and was an accomplished pod racer. i think he has the precision, and the brains to figure out how to use a pistol

Luke wins, Anakin doesn't know how to use a blaster, Luke'd run up to him and cut him with the saber, if Anakin did shoot at him Luke might block it as he did with the Romote Droid but he might not cause he's not that good.

Wow, vpokdekjyafmidp one thread you say he was stupid, the next you say Anakin was smart...

Originally posted by Arker
...

Anakin: *Stares blankly at the blaster*
Luke: AHHHHHHHHH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! WTF, I'M GONNA FREAKING KILL YOU!!!!!!!!!!! AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH!!!!!!!!!!
Anakin: *Scratches head*
Luke: GAAHHHHHHHHHHHH!!!!! *Slashes the air*
Anakin: *Hits trigger on accident and shoots Luke's leg.*
Luke: Gah! Damn it, you ****ing bastard!!!!!!
Anakin: Wha? Wait, I hit him! Yippee!!!
Luke: *Head explodes*

So, now you know that Anakin wins.

Head explodes?? what are you talking about neither of them use the force.

Really there are only 2 ways Anakin wins.

1- he get's lucky

2- the contest is who is the most annoying. or for worst lines/acting

funniest line from the OT after watching the PT

"He was already a great pilot when I met him"

What's funny about that. He was a great pilot.

R2 did all the work! Unless you're talking about podracers he sucked.

He obviously didn't know what was going on when he was in the cockpit of that naboo fighter.

Originally posted by Guy LeDouche
Wow, vpokdekjyafmidp one thread you say he was stupid, the next you say Anakin was smart...

ROTS Anakin made a stupid move while fighting obi-wan, TPM Anakin was a smart boy for his age

AND OK LETS ASSUME HE KNOWS HOW TO USE A BLASTER PISTOL

Luke.

Anakin never used a blaster that we know and Luke did have some training in deflecting blaster bolts in ANH so Luke would win.

Originally posted by docb77
Head explodes?? what are you talking about neither of them use the force.

Really there are only 2 ways Anakin wins.

1- he get's lucky

2- the contest is who is the most annoying. or for worst lines/acting

I think anyone's head would explode after Anakin's "Yippee!!!"...

Obviously no one here's head did.

seriously ANH luke sucks ass, and IF anakin knew how to use a blaster, and they were a fair distance away from eachother, anakin would get a few shots in. definately engough to kill him

Luke wasn't bad with a blaster. Watch him with Leia when he shoots all the stormtroopers. Also when he hits the codes for the blast doors. Also, destroying the deathstar...... He doesn't suck.

but anakin has the blaster