Originally posted by Faunus
You disgrace everyone. . . All of your arguments are based on gameplay. I had Juhani pwn Bandon. I guess she can beat Sidious, too.
None of my arguments are based on gameplay. I said Sidious defeating 2 masters almost as good as Kenobi is no big deal. Sheesh, don't take it so seriously 🙁 🙂
Originally posted by zephiel7
In lightsaber combat Sidious most likely gets WTFpwned, but in terms of force it would be a close call.
Yes, Sidious would lose in lightsaber combat, but DE Sidious trumps Revan big time in force powers.
Originally posted by zephiel7
Sidious [B]most likely narrowly beat out Revan with his ability to conjure giant force storms that can destroy fleets, but Revan has been able to use the force storm ability too. [/B]
The force storm that Revan used in KOTOR is not the same ability that Sidious used. KOTOR force storms are just a higher level of force lightning. Even if they were the same ability, look at the scale that each one has been used on. Destroying capital ships or fighting people.
Originally posted by zephiel7
This is is speculation too, but in his duel against Malak, he was able to shrug of a force storm aswell, so that would show that his talent in the force could protect him from Sidious's attacks, much like Sidious would be protected from Revans force attacks.
Once again, it isn't the same ability in KOTOR, so as far as we know, Revan has never defended himself against a force storm. And again, it's all about scale. Sidious' attack is hundreds of times bigger.
Originally posted by zephiel7
Revan also has the advantage of battle experience. He has fought several dark Jedi on board the Star Forge, Malak's ship, the Rakatan planet, and the several world's that he visited on his quest for the Star Forge. As the Dark Lord, he was adept at fighting Jedi.So I'd have to go Revan
Yes, Revan does have battle experience, but that is only going to help him in lightsaber combat, which we already know he would win in. Sidious has had much more training time and has fought some extremely tough opponents like Yoda and Mace, who on their own are about as good as Malak. Furthermore, that was back in ROTS. In DE he is ridiculously overpowered. There really is no way that Revan can win if Sidious can keep it a force battle.
Sidious has had much more training time and has fought some extremely tough opponents like Yoda and Mace
I suppose arguing force powers is pointless since we don't know enough about Revan. DE Sidious takes Revan in force storm but I dont think the Revster will give Sid's the time required to charge up for his ubermensch force storm.
Originally posted by zephiel7
He's more than fantastic, he's Revan! 😈
Yes, because that's what's going to win him this fight.
DE Sidious wins him. His lightsaber abilities are way underrated. If you're talking about experience, he had decades of years of experience where he learned all sorts of forms and force powers.