Poll
0%
0%
0%
0%
11%
0%
56%
22%
11%
0%
TPM Obi-Wan and Qui-Gon run the gauntlet
They get full rest between each battle. If one of them dies they don't come back. If either of them loses limbs during a duel they don't grow back for the next one battle. Where do they go down?
1. AOTC Anakin
2. AOTC Obi-Wan
3. ROTS Shaak Ti
4. Cin Drallig
5. ROTS General Grievous
6. Old Ben (ANH)
7. Asajj and Durge (from Obsession)
8. ROTS Count Dooku
1. AOTC Anakin - He gets pwnd, since either alone could beat him.
2. AOTC Obi-Wan - he puts up a better fight and lasts longer due to his Soresu skills but really isn't much of a match for both of these Jedi at once.
3. ROTS Shaak Ti - Well, she's a Makashi rracticioner so she's probably better at dueling than either of them but they definately pull it off and both come out alive.
4. Cin Drallig - They'd have some trouble with Cin, he'd probably use Makashi (I'm assuming he knows it since he's a lightsaber instructor) unless he's better with a different form. The duo could probably pull it off without either dying but it'd be hard.
5. ROTS General Grievous - If he kills one of them I highly doubt the other'd stand a chance. I think the duo could probably do it, but it'd be extremely close.
6. Old Ben (ANH) - They might go down here, unless Ben gets tired before he can kill both of them. I'll say he manages to kill Qui-Gon but is so exhausted from the effort that he loses to TPM Obi-Wan (especially if, after Qui-Gon dies, Obi-Wan attacks him like he attacked Maul after he killed Qui-Gon in TPM).
7. Asajj and Durge (from Obsession) - Obi gets WTF pwnd, even if Qui-Gon is still with him Durge put up a good fight against Obi and Ani at the same time in Obsession, with Asajj the duo stand nearly no chance,
8. ROTS Count Dooku - If by some miracle the duo makes it here they get pwnd, Maul nearly took both of them and Dooku stood up to Yoda and pwnd ROTS Obi-Wan while fending off Anakin.
So I say Qui-Gon dies at 6, Obi-Wan at 7.
Why is Ben way up there? He's pretty weak by ANH.
By ANH, all Ben can do is stalemate OT Vader.
WTF? The entire purpose of him being on Tatooine was too watch over Luke and, when he was ready, train him. Both of those would be failry hard to do if he'd had no practice for the better part of two decades, wouldn't you think? Not to mention that he's busy with whatever Force training Yoda and Qui-Gon have laid out for him.
Originally posted by Arker
Ben isn't strong at all in ANH. He was ultimately weakened because of twenty years of no training or practicing with the Force, and he'd probably even lose to his padawan self. They'd get passed his with ease.
Ben is very strong.
Why wouldn't he train, the training he had from Yoda? Also, he has a lightsaber right there. To say he didn't use it or didn't train, would be a foolish statement.
TPM Obi-Wan would most certainly not beat ANH Ben.
This would be a tough fight for them.
Originally posted by Darth Traya
What? The ANH Novelisation which is written by Lucas, has Ben and Vader being virtually equal.
Originally posted by Guy LeDouche
Ben is very strong.Why wouldn't he train, the training he had from Yoda? Also, he has a lightsaber right there. To say he didn't use it or didn't train, would be a foolish statement.
TPM Obi-Wan would most certainly not beat ANH Ben.
This would be a tough fight for them.
Obi-Wan had given up after the fall of the Republic. His only purpose after that was to eventually train Luke to destroy the Empire. He didn't need to keep training to teach Luke because all he needs is the knowledge of the Force. If he'd have kept training, he would probably be stronger than Vader. But in ANH, they are about equal. Ben Kenobi was not the Jedi Knight he used to be.
because neither of them had trained extensivley in saber to saber combat, simply because it was practically non existant in tpm id guess they lose at grievous. qui gon would keep cin busy while obi wan tries to finish it and theyd probably win, but grievous is trained by dooku as a jedi killer, all he does is saber to saber, and with his weird form and style and their inexperience with sabers theyd be overwhelmed. intimidation and fear are definitley on the generals side.