ROTJ Luke vs. TPM Obi-Wan (READ THE FIRST POST!!)

I am fully aware that there are quite a few ROTJ Luke vs. TPM Obi-Wan threads on who would win in a fight, but now let's look at their personalities. Both were in their twenties, both were fairly cool, level-headed, grown-up and also a bit brash, having tapped into the dark side to defeat their opponents. And both would easily trample over AOTC Anakin in terms of personality as well. So who do you think has the better personality and why?

ROTJ Luke.

OT characters > PT "characters"

Luke was always slightly annoying and whiny in ANH and ESB, he was cool in ROTJ however, but I like Obi-Wan a lot more as a character...So..

Obi-Wan

yeah, luke was an idiot for going after vader

Yup. I think Obi is cooler.

Obi-Wan Christ.

Obi-Wan Keninja.

Kenobi.

TPM Kenobi>AotC Anakin>RotJ Luke

Simple, no?

you actually think AOTC Anakin has a better personality than ROTJ Luke?

I liked how in charge of things Luke seemed most of the time in ROTJ, but Obi-wan is the better character overall.

Obi Wan pwns Luke.. I mean he's Obi Wan. He's the greatest Jedi eva.

Obi-Wan is a lot cooler than I wanna go to the toshi station to pick up some power converters! Skywalker.

I say Luke is the cooler character. Up until "General Kenobi" and the Mysterious Hermit, Ben, Luke is cooler. Episode 3 and 4 Ben kick ass, and are about as cool as Luke "ROTJ Force Choke" Skywalker.

Originally posted by vpokdekjyafmidp
yeah, luke was an idiot for going after vader

Luke went after vader makes him stupid? why? didn't luke beat the shit out of him?

Luke was whiny? I don't remember that

Luke wins of course Luke did beat Vader with little training.....

TPM OBI isn't even close to beating Vader...

Luke wins, even though we don't like him for some reason, probably because how he looks.

Luke went after vader makes him stupid? why? didn't luke beat the shit out of him?

Yep, I mean, Vader wasn't conflicted in his killing of Luke. Yep, Vader never threw the fight...

Luke was whiny? I don't remember that

"But Uncle Owen! I wanted to go into the Tochi station to pick up some power converters!"

Luke wins of course Luke did beat Vader with little training.....

Read my first response...

TPM OBI isn't even close to beating Vader...

He has a far better chance of beating Vader than Luke...

Luke wins, even though we don't like him for some reason, probably because how he looks.

I sense Lord Fanboy is in dangah...

Yea, they sensed he was in danger, but he really wasn't >.>

Yes he was, oh yes he was...

He has a far better chance of beating Vader than Luke...

To be fair, Luke was the only person less powerful than Vader who could effectively destroy him (or save him). Obi stands a better chance power-wise... but Yoda sent Luke out there for a reason.

Wait, you're saying Luke was level-headed? Did you even glimpse at the Vader vs. Luke fight? Luke was a mad man. In the Obi-Wan vs. Maul fight, there wasn't an instant where Obi-Wan let his anger get the best of him.

Anyways, Obi-Wan was pretty quiet in TPM. He was kind of cooler too. Obi-Wan has a better personality.

In the Obi-Wan vs. Maul fight, there wasn't an instant where Obi-Wan let his anger get the best of him.

Uh, watch the end of the fight... Right after Qui-Gon gets killed.