Odan Urr versus Vodo Siosk-Bass

Yeah, I'm glad you've conjured up all this evidence for your case...

Oh, wait.

LOL.. You're right, Palpatine WASN'T a politician.. And Odan Urr DIDNT spend the majority of his life in his books... For someone telling me to read GOATH, you sure sound like you haven't yourself.

Says the idiot who just got his ass handed to him by the scans, right?

"PALPATINE WAS MERELY A POLITICIAN, HE ARE SUXXOR IN COMBAT!"

"Here he is doing a respectable job against Mace Windu."

"zOMG"

tdtd logic, everyone.

Apparently...

What do you think Palpatine did? Found a dark corner in his office and practiced lightsaber skills?

Are you that dumb that you don't understand the concept of a politician or a scholar. Michael Jordan is a ball player, doesn't mean he can't do anything else right? Speaking of logic, what was the main role of Vodo, and what was the main role of Odan? One was a warrior one was a scholar.. Quit while you're behind.

Except you've provided... jack shit for evidence regarding your inane assumptions. In order to put me behind, you are required to prove up with logic and evidence, troll.

Originally posted by tdtd
Michael Jordan is a ball player, doesn't mean he can't do anything else right?

And Odan-Urr is a scholar, doesn't mean he can't do anything else, right?

Don't be stupid. Provide evidence or provide silence.

Evidence that Palpatine was a politician? Watch the movies nitwit. Evidence that Odan Urr aka THE SCHOLAR was indeed a scholar, and not a warrior? Read GAOTH. Your reading comprehension skills are lacking.

I don't need evidence that Palpatine was a politician. Don't be a smartass.

Your logic is failing where my reading is lacking, in that case. You have provided NO evidence that Odan-Urr lacks any skill in combat whatsoever. Like I said, evidence or silence, Tdtd.

I wasn't talking to you Rex. I was pointing out that Vodo was a warrior and Odan was a scholar, nowhere did I say that neither one of them could do anything else. But when you geniuses compare the jedi of the PT and the Jedi of the Sith Wars or KOTOR, your logic is the more powerful jedi are the ones that are constantly involved in battle, military, etc... Vodo was constantly doing this, while Odan although did fight, spent most of his time in the library. This is your own logic.

Evidence that Palpatine was a politician? Watch the movies nitwit.

And this by your logic means he can't fight for shit, despite his respectable performance against Windu. Good job with the self-ownage, troll.

Evidence that Odan Urr aka THE SCHOLAR was indeed a scholar, and not a warrior? Read GAOTH. Your reading comprehension skills are lacking.

If my reading comprehension is lacking, you're ****ing blind:

Quod Erat Demonstrandum

All I heard was 'No evidence.'

that's nice except you still fail to show me where I said they can't do anything other than their titles? And IKC, you ave reading comprehension problems fanboy.

Except you've consistantly failed to provide evidence that their roles are rock-solid and unchanging, despite the fact that Odan fought in a war that far surpasses anything Vodo's lived through.

Keep going though, troll. Dig yourself in deeper.

Rock solid and unchanging? Who's digging themselves deeper here? Stop lying to yourself fanboy. Odan spent the majority of his life as a scholar, Vodo spent the majority of his life as a warrior, if they went head to head Vodo would have more experience wouldn't he? Thank you, stop living in denial.

Stop lying to yourself fanboy.

Stop talking out of your ass, troll.

Odan spent the majority of his life as a scholar,

Prove up. Saying it doesn't make it true, Goebbels.

Vodo spent the majority of his life as a warrior,

Prove up. Saying it doesn't make it true, Goebbels.

if they went head to head Vodo would have more experience wouldn't he?

Not necessarily, because Odan lived and fought through a conflict far worse than anything Vodo has ever witnessed.

Thank you, stop living in denial.

Learn to debate, child.

I have to agree with IKC. Your debating material isn't much to look at. It's mostly insults.

Yea insulting the intellectually inferior. I'm glad your debate skills go as far as a star wars forum IKC. However until you show me what else Odan Urr was involved in besides those few little pages in GOATH sith, I am forced to believe that Odan Urr was a scholar, he spent his time in the library in the beginning of the comics, and spent his time at the library at the end of his life... Now stop lying to yourself fanboy.

Originally posted by tdtd
Rock solid and unchanging? Who's digging themselves deeper here? Stop lying to yourself fanboy. Odan spent the majority of his life as a scholar, Vodo spent the majority of his life as a warrior, if they went head to head Vodo would have more experience wouldn't he? Thank you, stop living in denial.

And this shows what, exactly?

If I'm a scholar who can tool Michael Jordan in ball, what does that indicate?

No context. Prove up.

That indicates that you are multitalented beyond belief, and a basketball god. Throughout the comics all Vodo did was fight and train fighters, while Odan Urr was in the library.