Originally posted by w00t2112
Yet, the evidence of the amulet blasts affecting force users is a unknown, as you said "theoretically" does not make it so, however i still think Kun tools them both with force powers or lightsaber superiority
Freedon Nadd seemed to have no answer for it. It's not like you can attack Sith Spirits usually, JA Luke (which is after DE) seemed to have plenty of trouble getting rid of Exar Kun's spirit. It did affect a powerful Sith Spirit, it's empowered by the dark side, so why wouldn't it affect a force user?
Originally posted by w00t2112
In that case, DN Luke would be wiped out, something many people dont agree, but i do.
Well in that case I can say emerald lightning can affect force users only to have Kun fanboys tell me that it is a unknown... So how are you going to rate Kun's amulet blasts above emerald lightning and vice versa?
Originally posted by tdtd
Well in that case I can say emerald lightning can affect force users only to have Kun fanboys tell me that it is a unknown... So how are you going to rate Kun's amulet blasts above emerald lightning and vice versa?
It was a matter of opinion, i have not gone and said, it definitely affects force users, but killing a monster as opposed as a Vong is certianly more impressive.
Originally posted by Illustrious
Freedon Nadd seemed to have no answer for it. It's not like you can attack Sith Spirits usually, JA Luke (which is after DE) seemed to have plenty of trouble getting rid of Exar Kun's spirit. It did affect a powerful Sith Spirit, it's empowered by the dark side, so why wouldn't it affect a force user?
I think this answers it. If Kun can WTFpwn Nadd's powerful spirit with the amulet, it stands to reason that it IS effective against force users, whereas Luke's emerald lightning isn't.
Btw, everything you've ever said about that lightning, tdtd, has been almost word for word from Wookieepedia.
Originally posted by tdtd
What does it matter champ? It exists? Youre going to deny it's existence? You have to treat Kun's amulet blasts the same way you treat the Emerald Lightning. Since it's all speculation either they both work on force users or they don't.
No, it's not. The amulet was used against Freedan Nadd, who could WTFpwn force users even as a spirit. And keep in mind that this spirit was considered "powerless" compared to his tangible living form. If Freedan Nadd, patron of Onderon and disciple of Naga Sadow couldn't defend against it in the hands of Exar Kun, I highly doubt that DN Luke will fare better.
And on the flip side, Luke's emerald lightning appears to have worked on a nonforce sensitive. That would be like seeing Sidious only shock a regular human and then deduce that Yoda couldn't catch it with his bare hands. It's a false conclusion.
Well he did use it against a being outside of the force, and if other force attacks didn't work against them its quite impressive. We also don't really know if the Amulet could have done shit against Nadd if he was still alive. Actually I'm pretty sure it couldn't have Nadd seems pretty uber. But it is logical to assume that the amulet would at least hurt a force user. To say it would instantly kill them on impact however... I wouldn't be to sure about that.
Well, maybe not the fireball itself, but the hatred it channels can affect a force user even as sly and powerful as Nadd, which is really saying something. And while Luke's emerald lightning might be a potent attack, it also might be something Kun can easily absorb or reflect. We just have no instance of it being used on a force user, so it's effect is in question.