ESB Luke Skywalker vs Hanna and Scout (Dark Rendezvous)

Can these two amazing 13 year old Apprentices take down the 20 year old noob Jedi?

Fights on... Bespin, where Luke and Vader fought in ESB.

If they are trully amazing like you say, then yes.

ESB Luke is 22, not 20. he beats the Padawans.

Luke loses. The Padawans of the PT era are relatively better than Luke in general.

Luke managed to get a hit in on Vader. Whether he was holding back or not I sitll highly doubt these two could have done that.

granted after he got that hit, vader ended it very quickly, but he still got the hit and managed to survive. I know it wasnt Vaders plan to kill him, but lasted longer than most people would.

Originally posted by Darth Subjekt
granted after he got that hit, vader ended it very quickly, but he still got the hit and managed to survive. I know it wasnt Vaders plan to kill him, but lasted longer than most people would.

Vader wouldn't want to capture most people, he would want to kill most people.

But even judging by the choreography, Luke was very, very impressive with a saber for 2 weeks of training.

Granted, he's not as good as the average PTer, but he was still very good.

Scout was weak with the Force. She'd be no competition for Luke. Hanna's a ***** and would go down like a *****.

Scout is quite physically capable though. And Hanna is very powerful for an Apprentice. Hell, there was a lineup of Masters for her.

Can these padawans resist force choke? Luke killed 2 Gammoreans in the matter of seconds with only waving his hand, and Anakin (without barley knowing the power) killed Serra Keto who was one of the most promising students with it. (and she was a jedi knight). So I don't know.

Originally posted by kamikz
Can these padawans resist force choke? Luke killed 2 Gammoreans in the matter of seconds with only waving his hand, and Anakin (without barley knowing the power) killed Serra Keto who was one of the most promising students with it. (and she was a jedi knight). So I don't know.

Luke did not kill them, he stunned them. Killing takes longer, regardless of power.

And anyway, Jedi are trained from youngling stage to resist telekinesis...

Yet ROTS Obi-Wan was unable to block Dooku's.

Oh I thought it was ROTJ Luke, well then Luke probably looses.

Originally posted by darthsith19
Yet ROTS Obi-Wan was unable to block Dooku's.

I think we should disregard that as a mistake. It makes a lot more sense that Jedi would be able to counter Force-kinesis. The novel has a much better version of the 'Anakin & Kenobi vs Dooku' fight.

What happened there?

Originally posted by kamikz
What happened there?

Dooku nailed Kenobi with a wheel kick, then Force-threw him. Being stunned from the kick, Kenobi was unable to block it as he usually would (it was a REALLY strong kick and it landed while he was distracted.)

Originally posted by chilled monkey
I think we should disregard that as a mistake. It makes a lot more sense that Jedi would be able to counter Force-kinesis. The novel has a much better version of the 'Anakin & Kenobi vs Dooku' fight.