The Authority vs. The Golden Age JSA

The Authority's lineup:
Jenny Sparks
Rose Tattoo
Swift
Apollo
Jack Hawksmoor
Midnighter
Engineer
And let's throw in Elijah Snow, Fuji, and Hellstrike just because

vs.

JSA's lineup:
Superman
Flash I
Green Lantern I
Wonder Woman
Hawkman
Sand (Subbing in for Sandman just because 😈 )
Fate
Hourman
Batman
Atom
Doctor Mid-Nite
Starman
Mr. Terrific II (Subbing in for Mr Terrific I because I like him better)
Wildcat
Black Canary

Note that both Spectre and Doctor have been left off the list for obvious reasons

Who takes this good ole fashion Slobberknocker?

Fight's too big...too hard to make an accurate judgement.

Besides Superman, who was written ridiculously inconsistent but had some great feats, most of the Golden Age people were less powerful than their modern-day counterparts. For that reason alone I'd hand it to the Authority.

Make it current though, and without the Doctor or Jenny Quantum, the Authority would be in some trouble.

What if I were to trim down the lineups to something like this:

The Authority's lineup:
Jenny Sparks
Rose Tattoo
Swift
Apollo
Jack Hawksmoor
Midnighter
Engineer
Elijah Snow (balance)

vs.

JSA's lineup:
Superman
Flash I
Green Lantern I
Wonder Woman
Hawkman
Sand
Fate
Hourman
Batman
Johnny Thunder

happy 😛

Gets rid of most the Street Levelers that would likely be killed in rather gruesome manners by Midnighter and I figured adding Sand and Fate would maybe make things closer. :/

Still no Thunder?

heh almost completely forgot about JT