Most Disappointing Album

What album or albums was most disappointing to you? Not necessarily the worst album you ever heard, but the one that you had high hopes for and was terrible.

I have a feeling With Teeth is going to be mentioned.

With Teeth doesn't qualify for me, because as RedAlert said, although it was very poor, I personally expected it to be. Everyone else seemed to be kneeling in hope of the Second Coming, with little precedent providing a reason to do so.

i thought the strokes "room on fire" was pretty disappointing...they more than made up for it with first impressions of earth though

didn't think much of jesse malin's second album...the heat...his first album "the fine art of self destruction" was great

I would have to say that when I listened to Sum 41's most recent album, "Chuck" I was pretty disappointed. Now I know they're not the best band in the world, but they usually produce some catchy/fun-to-listen to stuff. I just didn't feel that with the newest album. Meh.

Northstars "Pollyanna" was great, so I assumed their second album would be too and I bought it

❌

With Teeth

Mezmerize. I preferred their older stuff, and the big change just ut me off completely.

With Teeth for me, very disappointing.

-AC

Metallicas ST Anger. Almost killed me listening to it.

Hypnotise by system of a don

Hear Say: Pure and Simple ...

I was only like 7 when I bought it, but what a waste of money ❌

Originally posted by Valharu
Metallicas ST Anger. Almost killed me listening to it.

Did it, really?

-AC

Originally posted by Eternal Turmoil
Hear Say: Pure and Simple ...

I was only like 7 when I bought it, but what a waste of money ❌

I loved that album at the time 😮

Ras Kass- Rasassination

😬 after listening to 'Soul on Ice', i was sure this would be as great. And i was completley wrong. There are some great songs such as 'Conceited Bastard', 'Interview with a Vampire', 'H20 Proof', and 'Rasassination'...but the rest of the album doesn't follow 😬

3.5/5 <----and im being very generous

American Idiot

Originally posted by dani_california
American Idiot

Why?

Metallica - St Anger - repetitive songs, sounding uninspired, and no guitar solos. I've never heard something as bad as this and so disappointing for a band as big as Metallica.

Most recently for me is SMiLE. I got Pet Sounds before hand and it was fantastic. So naturally, after hearing so much good news about SMiLE I decided to get - very disappointing. However, it's starting to grow on me.

Originally posted by Nevermind
Most recently for me is SMiLE. I got Pet Sounds before hand and it was fantastic. So naturally, after hearing so much good news about SMiLE I decided to get - very disappointing. However, it's starting to grow on me.

I think Smile is excellent.