Respect Judge Dredd

No. Mark Millar would ruin the Punisher. I'd say either the guy who wrote the Taskmaster mini, or Garth Ennis.

Not Millar, Miller. Frank Miller.

Enemy Of The State was such a let down. Garth Ennis would do well for Pun, but I dunno if he could pull off Dredd.

True. Yeah, Frank Miller would be awesome. Mark Millar is gonna get a visit from a bullet if he ruins Civil War.

Frank Miller's great but I prefer it when he works alongside Mazzuchelli, his art isnt as good...

Mazzuchelli was excellent choice for Born Again. I like Miller's art better in monochrome, as I said for the Sin Cities.

Born Again is fantastic...

Yeah, it was excellent. Didn't like the Nuke stuff though. The beginning was better, where Matt was going loopy.

Anyway, we're a bit off topic.

Dredd isn't invincible so i will show a battle's which he lose's as well as wins.. simply because he has the guts to go against them knowing he isn't the favourite to win it..

Here..
Dredd battles Armon Gill for the 2nd time.
http://i62.photobucket.com/albums/h117/streekz/dreddlaw1.jpg
http://i62.photobucket.com/albums/h117/streekz/dreddlaw2.jpg
http://i62.photobucket.com/albums/h117/streekz/dreddlaw3.jpg
http://i62.photobucket.com/albums/h117/streekz/dreddlaw4.jpg
http://i62.photobucket.com/albums/h117/streekz/dreddlaw5.jpg

Here...
Dredd even though injuried still goes to take care of Armon Gill. (3rd battle with Armon Gill)
http://i62.photobucket.com/albums/h117/streekz/dreddlaw6.jpg
http://i62.photobucket.com/albums/h117/streekz/dreddlaw8.jpg

Nice fight. He's a toughie.

Remember, the person doesn't have to win the fight for it to be a respect feat. He could have lost, yet gained the upper hand at some point, or made a good showing, or escaped in an impressive way.

Armon Gill is very tough, he is a genetically modified soldier so i would say it is a feat to take him down when any normal human wouldn't really have a chance. Before the battle that Dredd lost, Armon had killed about 4 or 5 judges.

I've got a Dredd vs Cap thread up in Versus forum. Check it out, guys!

Originally posted by Thunderstrike
Dredd and Punisher would get along perfectly.

Why? They both kill for the law's purposes.

dredd would see punisher as a vigilante, he hates vigilante's..
dredd can be too much towards the law thats why he had problems with batman. frank castle would make a good judge though..

I would like to do my own topic for Dredd like this but is more than one allowed because this one seems a bit messy.