Best Star Wars "No!"

Started by PVS3 pages

as said before, and was apparently ignored, luke did NOT scream "no" in RotJ. read the subtitles.

It wasn't ignored, it was the topic of many posts! You can't, however, change a poll once it's started.

Our clues are it sounds like "No!" and the annoted screenplay says it's a "No!" Then again the close-captioning says it's a "Never!" and so do many people.

What does the actor's mouth do? Does it move up and down with the sound of two syllables, or just open wide for a one-syllable interjection? Well, it's dark and it's hard to see! Hamill's arm comes up covering his mouth for a moment, then the shadow of his arm does the same, (J'ever notice in SW mouths are often covered by arms to make dubbing easier?) I'd bet Lucas most assuredly dubbed the word, so what we're watching is probably not what was yelled on the set.

I always thought it was "No!" because you never saw his mouth move twice in the "Never!" motion. But it's not that clear. It's either a very poorly pronounced "No!" or a very bad "Never!"

If I had a mixer and could slow it down that might help. I think I still have the ROTJ storybook in LP somewhere and I could take it to a DJ!

what about anakins no in ROTS right before he cuts of windus hand

Originally posted by Rampant ox
Thanks. I was starting to think it was just me who likes it. I also like that part because it is Vaders final duel. The music coupled with the scene is just amazing.

im suprised that wasnt in the list, because it aint all that bad 馃槢

P.S. If theres one person who has contributed to Star Wars throughout all Six episodes that hasnt let me down, It has to be John Williams by far, hes the best!!!

Originally posted by chinabing
Our clues are it sounds like "No!" and the annoted screenplay says it's a "No!" Then again the close-captioning says it's a "Never!" and so do many people.

i dont think it sounds anything like "no". sounds more like "darth" imho

granted, it should have been "no"

Luke in ep. V of course... 馃檮

I liked Darth Vader's NOOOOOO!!! the best.

Originally posted by PVS
i dont think it sounds anything like "no". sounds more like "darth" imho
granted, it should have been "no"

Maybe Hamill was sick and tired of saying "No!" He put his foot down and said "Dammit George, can't I say something different?!"

"NO!"

Originally posted by Jedi Priestess
TESB: Luke at discovering his parentage

I am your father and Darth vader discovering padme died

What about Yodas Nos?

1) "No, No, Noooo, stay and help you I will"
2) "Nooo! Nooooooooo!" "R2, let him have it..."
3) "Is the darkside stronger?" "No, no..."

Yoda has a cute nose.