Royal SW Throwdown Fight

Originally posted by Jonathan Mark
Actually like the majority of Post-ROTJ material... the DE comics fekking suck.

1. Palpatine should have stayed dead... none of the this clone bullshit.

2. Luke should have never fallen to the Dark Side, that completely contradicts the movies.

3. The Storyline was horrid.

Really the DE comics suck.

How do the comics contradict the movies? They are after the movies, they really have little to do with the movies... I understand you don't like it but it's your opinion, doesn't mean they contradict anything.

Indeed, considering Anakin was the Chosen One, said to destroy the Sith once and for all, and he did in ROTJ, yet DE contradicts it by bringing the Sith back, that was supposedly "destroyed" as a result of Vader.

tdtd it contradicts the prophesy.

It's not that severe, though. DE Palpatine can be considered a "fake Sith" since he was just a clone.

I do not approve what they're doing with Legacy. Bull ****ing ****. They're bringing back entirely new Sith. Not Dark Jedi, but Sith.

So much for the prophecy, eh?

Originally posted by tdtd
Let me get this straight. An Ancient Sith and Kun vs. 2 black men? Remind me how Kun isn't the first to go?

If this reason is not enough though...

Sadow seems stronger than all of them. Mace and Kar are physical beasts, and Exar Kun is no chump. However I think in brute strength I think he is the weakest link.

Tough call here. I still think the Sith will take it. It would be a funny battle though.

Originally posted by tdtd
How do the comics contradict the movies? They are after the movies, they really have little to do with the movies... I understand you don't like it but it's your opinion, doesn't mean they contradict anything.

I personally feel that DE contradicts Luke's persona when he fell. And I mean, he fell within seconds. He held out much longer in ROTJ, when he was a hell of a lot weaker than Sidious.

And at the same time DE Sidious was a hell of a lot stronger and Luke felt that he was fighting an immortal enemy did he not?

Which he shouldn't have... it's not the same body and the midi-chlorian theory totally blows away the idea of making clone bodies unless one can replicate midi-chlorians. If Sidious could do that, he didn't NEED Anakin or Luke.

Right but what's to say that Sidious didn't finally learn the technique that he talked about Darth Plagueis having? Actually we see that he DID develop the technique, whether the same one or not, to cheat death effectively, but not until somewhere in between ESB and ROTJ, when he was on Korriban first.. But of course that's an assumption of where he developed it, we just know he developed it before ROTJ.

No, there's nothing to suggest Sidious has the knowledge and again, why would he need or want Luke or Anakin if he has control over midi-chlorians and has clone bodies?

And what if the clone turned against him? Thats maybe what he might have feared. I know I would rather have a secondary leader weaker than myself, so that I wouldent have to worry about something like that.

I'm pretty sure he could make a clone obediant to him. The Kaminoans did a fine job on their own.

Yes, but the clones were programmed to follow orders from a leader I believe. I dont think Sids could make a clone obediant to him when his clone is equally as powerful as he is.

Originally posted by Janus Marius
No, there's nothing to suggest Sidious has the knowledge and again, why would he need or want Luke or Anakin if he has control over midi-chlorians and has clone bodies?

What do you mean there is nothing to suggest? He told Anakin that there was a way to cheat death, you're saying that him transferring his spirit into clones isn't that technique? Or even logically possible? And again he must have learned this technique before ROTJ and after ESB.

Originally posted by tdtd
What do you mean there is nothing to suggest? He told Anakin that there was a way to cheat death, you're saying that him transferring his spirit into clones isn't that technique? Or even logically possible? And again he must have learned this technique before ROTJ and after ESB.

Yeah, I guess a sith lord wouldn't lie to manipulate a potential recruit... cuz, he only did that with Dooku. Sidious was likely lying out of his ass.

Originally posted by Janus Marius
Yeah, I guess a sith lord wouldn't lie to manipulate a potential recruit... cuz, he only did that with Dooku. Sidious was likely lying out of his ass.

I like how Darth Sidious, master manipulator, is suddenly not kidding when he is speaking to Anakin and trying to convert him.

Originally posted by tdtd
Let me get this straight. An Ancient Sith and Kun vs. 2 black men? Remind me how Kun isn't the first to go?

😆 😆 😆 😆 😆 I WAS THINKIGN THE SAME THING 😆 😆 😆 😆 😆

Assuming that Naga's strength is in the same ballpark as Ludo's, he's got this. Ludo broke a Sith Sword with his bare hands. Probably the single most impressive display of physical strength in the SW Universe.

He smashed it on a table, yeah. I'd say Chewie literally tearing the limbs off of several Trandoshans is equally impressive.

Originally posted by Janus Marius
I like how Darth Sidious, master manipulator, is suddenly not kidding when he is speaking to Anakin and trying to convert him.

You're not understanding what I'm saying. I'm saying and this is a logical assumption, that he did not learn the technique until somewhere between ESB and ROTJ, maybe on Korriban or maybe not, but he obviously had A technique of cheating death, unless of course the DE series isn't canon.