Hayden or Hamill

I preferred Hayden over Hamill his acting was much better everyone says he was an arrogant little jerk in Ep II but that was what he was written as Hayden just played the character as he was told i wasnt impressed with Hamill at all and btw when people say Star Wars i dont think Luke Skywalker i think Darth Vader immediately he is the true icon from the trilogy

Yep, Darth Vader IS SW

Plus, he had to pattern his speech off of Hamills And Darth Vaders, to effect the slow pronounciation of some of his dialogue.... to give you the impression that its HIS voice in the suit in IV-VI

Indeed. I still thought of Hammil as the superior actor giving the superior performace.

I think Hamil did a better job, but I think Hayden had some great faces in ROTS. Some of his stuff was great, especially the deepset eyes.

i look in anakins eyes and just get drawn in

vampire Hamill, hayden was just not showing any emotion as anakin, well except when he helps the emperor kill mace and the anger he shows before he fights obi wan. And Hamill showed emotion as luke happy,sad, upset,in pain but then again so did hayden as anakin when he was being burnt alive on mustafar

I find Anakin as a wimpy and he was too adicted to Padme and he really didnt do it well anyway where Hamill wasnt busy with love which makes hamill better

Some parts were attrocious.

You are beautiful like the sand

I hate sand.

lol! "You are beautful like sand"!

Lol. Sandpeople

vampire Luke only had relantionships in the expanded universe and eventually did marry and have a child after the fighting against the empire was over.

i say equal and if you think about it this is a bad thread because they both did their job, however i like hamill because he was in a family guy that made me laugh, lets see hayden do that, predator rocks!

Originally posted by aj_vader
i look in anakins eyes and just get drawn in

Originally posted by DePWNZOR
Yep, Darth Vader IS SW

No, but he was very.......

Vader-....ish.

Vader-like.

Yeah, he was Vader-like. 😛

Hayden *RAWR*

Hamill. Easy.

Originally posted by ((The_Anomaly))
As much as the character of Anakin is far better, Hamill acted Luke way better then Hayden acted Anakin...

😬

ACTED Anikan? Hayden was acting?

In EpIII the only decent acting came from Nute Gunray,Mace and Yoda.

Hamill because he was being directed by Lucas when Lucas was actually good at directing unlike now...

Hayden...it's like people said...Anakin's character is much more complex and he had to show different sides of him. Good, bad, wimpy lol...His permormance is exactly as Lucas told him...so don't give me that bad actor shit...To play a good guy and a villain at the same time is not easy, but Hayden played it well. Don't get me wrong. I liked Hamill's performance too, but it was easier to perform than Hayden's. And everybody is calling Hayden an whiner while Hamill was just doing the same...No it's just because the OT is sacred and the PT "sucks" that they come up with that excuse.

👆 ✅