Could Marvel vs DC actually be canon?

Started by Validus4 pages

Originally posted by snoopdogg
Dude calm down. It's ok for you to say Aquaman has a pis hand? Your actually fine with that?

If you don't like it learn to love it.


Yeah that was a bit hypocritical to say the least.

And there's no problem with Orin beating Namor. Only problem was using a whale to do it.

Originally posted by Validus
Yeah that was a bit hypocritical to say the least.

Excuse me? Don't tell me what I can and cannot say. It's a general term to call Aquaman's hand the Hand of Jobbing or Hand of PIS. If you don't like the fact that I call it that, then you can deal with it. I didn't insult him. It's a fact. That hand is a jobbing machine. Big whoop. To be honest, I'm getting sick and tired of all these cheap shots from the JLAKMC. Seriously. If somebody doens't like DC, you adamently dogpile onto them like a bunch of Nazis. You guys are a DC Jihad. I did nothing to provoke you, but you seem to enjoy attacking me. You wanna talk hypocrisy? You guys seem to enjoy representing a group that's all about the people, yet you piss on anyone who doesn't agree with you. That's hypocrisy. Look in the damn mirror.

By the bye, why on earth are you all accusing me of being ignorant when you refuse to listen to my side of the story?

Originally posted by snoopdogg
Does Thor have a pis hammer?

The Mjolnir is just that good. It can do nearly anything. Not as versatile as a GL ring and all the cool things it can do cough"boxing gloves and hammers"cough... But pretty damn effective. Then again Thor doesn't need the Mjolnir to summon his most deadly attacks. Ask Durok. Hmmm... If Supes got hit by a godblast that Durok got hit by... Supes would probably be dead.

Namor would have beat Aquaman. (no way around that)

Lobo would have beat Wolverine. (pfft)

Superman would have beat Hulk. (yep)

Elektra vs Catwoman...don't know, don't care.

Captain America vs Batman. In my copy Captain America wins. I agree (there's a lot of confusion regarding this)

Thor vs Shazaam. Thor wins

Flash vs Quicksilver. Flash wins.

SS vs Kyle GL. SS wins

So far I see only two things that aren't canon

I know a lot of people don't like wolverine beating Lobo in the DC/Marvel thing but that's what DC or who ever made the match ups get for matching the two up for a fan vote. They most likly thought hey no one who thinks about it would ever vote for wolverine but they didn't take into concideration that the people voteing didn't think about it they just thought he wolverine is the best their is at what he does.

Originally posted by jasofisc
I know a lot of people don't like wolverine beating Lobo in the DC/Marvel thing but that's what DC or who ever made the match ups get for matching the two up for a fan vote. They most likly thought hey no one who thinks about it would ever vote for wolverine but they didn't take into concideration that the people voteing didn't think about it they just thought he wolverine is the best their is at what he does.

But what he does is smoke, drink, and talk trash. Those aren't very nice.

the reason they were matched up is that Lobo was ORIGINALLY created to be wolverine marked to the extreme. Their CHARICTER looks are the same... lobo is just more extreme.

In case you were wondering why they fought.

Regardless... lobo would put wolverine on his hook and drag him about the galaxy, narrowly missing asteroids so wolverine runs into them.

and by the by, guys. You really shouldn't accuse TS of hypocricy when we all have a bit of that in us.

thanks for letting me know why they fought I thought it was just to make a match up were their was no way wolverine was going to win.

[quickquote=6399995](auto quote)[/quickquote]

To true .

was that... uh.... sarcasm?

Why are people so pedantic on these forums? We all make typos. My thoughts on the subject, is that it should be considered canon, because Access exists as a character, but many of those fight should never have happened. Hulk vs Lobo would sell better than Hulk vs Grundy IMO. Green Lantern seems to be ducking Quasar.... since Sentry wasn't around when they fought it should have been Gladiator vs Superman, Aquaman vs Namor, I was in Namors corner on that one... but I think they match up well. Thanos vs Darkseid was classic too bad they f**ked it up by not giving the paying customer what we all wanted... a drawn out slobber knocker... I think both companies ripped the consumer off by not going further with the story lines, the plot itself was horrible. Sorry I got a little off subject. but to answer whether or not I think that it was canon, I have two answers. Yes and No, for obvious reasons.

Originally posted by snoopdogg
After investigating my massive collection I found the issue. It's Green Lantern Vol.3 #87.

Here is a scan from the issue with Access and Jade.

Maybe Accel is on to something. I knew about it but forgot until he brang it to my attention.

http://i83.photobucket.com/albums/j286/doggydogg2/GLandAccess.jpg


Originally posted by snoopdogg
Hmmmmm check this out. This is another scan from GL #87.

Who do you suppose the guy with the surf board is?

http://i83.photobucket.com/albums/j286/doggydogg2/GLandAccess2.jpg


That's what I've been talking about! 😱
Thanks for the scans Snoop.

This is the reason I'm using to suggest that the crossover could be canon.

Originally posted by CaptainStoic
Why are people so pedantic on these forums? We all make typos. My thoughts on the subject, is that it should be considered canon, because Access exists as a character, but many of those fight should never have happened. Hulk vs Lobo would sell better than Hulk vs Grundy IMO. Green Lantern seems to be ducking Quasar.... since Sentry wasn't around when they fought it should have been Gladiator vs Superman, Aquaman vs Namor, I was in Namors corner on that one... but I think they match up well. Thanos vs Darkseid was classic too bad they f**ked it up by not giving the paying customer what we all wanted... a drawn out slobber knocker... I think both companies ripped the consumer off by not going further with the story lines, the plot itself was horrible. Sorry I got a little off subject. but to answer whether or not I think that it was canon, I have two answers. Yes and No, for obvious reasons.

Just because Access exists as a character doesnt make that crossover canon. For it to be treated as canon its events would have to be referenced in main continuity in both DC and Marvel. The Brothers would have to be referenced as the embodiments of the Marvel and DC multiverses. For all we know the Access that exists in DC might not be the same one that featured in that crossover.

Originally posted by Thunderstrike
Excuse me? Don't tell me what I can and cannot say. It's a general term to call Aquaman's hand the Hand of Jobbing or Hand of PIS. If you don't like the fact that I call it that, then you can deal with it. I didn't insult him. It's a fact. That hand is a jobbing machine. Big whoop. To be honest, I'm getting sick and tired of all these cheap shots from the JLAKMC. Seriously. If somebody doens't like DC, you adamently dogpile onto them like a bunch of Nazis. You guys are a DC Jihad. I did nothing to provoke you, but you seem to enjoy attacking me. You wanna talk hypocrisy? You guys seem to enjoy representing a group that's all about the people, yet you piss on anyone who doesn't agree with you. That's hypocrisy. Look in the damn mirror.

Just funny that you refer to his hand as PIS then when someone says the same thing about Mjolnir, half heartedly if i may say so, you jump down there throat like the immature fanboy you are. Hypocrite. 🙂

Originally posted by Magee
Just funny that you refer to his hand as PIS then when someone says the same thing about Mjolnir, half heartedly if i may say so, you jump down there throat like the immature fanboy you are. Hypocrite. 🙂

I was about to post that but whatever. 😛

It's odd you take a little joke on Mjolnir as a cheapshot when you go around using terms like Wonder B*tch or Superdick.

Referring to Aquaman's magic hand as the "Hand of Jobbing" or "Hand of PIS" isn't common at all. I've seen it used once on this forum in that X-Men/JLA thread where everyone was joking around.

Originally posted by Magee
Just funny that you refer to his hand as PIS then when someone says the same thing about Mjolnir, half heartedly if i may say so, you jump down there throat like the immature fanboy you are. Hypocrite. 🙂

Mine was a joke. You jump down my throat for insulting your favorite character when it was just a joke, and someone takes a cheap shot for no reason because he can't take the joke. That's fanboyish and hypocritical. Learn the definition of the word before throwing it around.

Originally posted by Validus
I was about to post that but whatever. 😛

It's odd you take a little joke on Mjolnir as a cheapshot when you go around using terms like Wonder B*tch or Superdick.

Referring to Aquaman's magic hand as the "Hand of Jobbing" or "Hand of PIS" isn't common at all. I've seen it used once on this forum in that X-Men/JLA thread where everyone was joking around.

I got pissed because Snoopdog made a personal attack, just like "this guy has a nice right" with Thor gettling clocked in one of the worst written fights I've ever seen. He adimently cheap shots me every time I get whenever I joke around about something.

Originally posted by GalacticStorm
Just because Access exists as a character doesnt make that crossover canon. For it to be treated as canon its events would have to be referenced in main continuity in both DC and Marvel. The Brothers would have to be referenced as the embodiments of the Marvel and DC multiverses. For all we know the Access that exists in DC might not be the same one that featured in that crossover.

That's similar to what I was thinking. It may be more of a fourth wall thing than anything else.