Wolverine vs. Captain America With a Twist...

Look, let's think about this.

Captain America is stronger than Wolverine when Wolvie has no healing factor. That is a fact. Cap doesn't need his shield if Wolvie doesn't have his claws anyway, so that's one more category down.

If the Captain were to dsiable Wolverine in some way, Wolverine could NOT heal back against it. That instantly takes him down a notch in durability. The Captain only has to worry about Logan's martial arts, and he is just the same in fighting skills. Plus, he is more controlled and doesn't lose temper straight off.

Steve wins.

Originally posted by Etrigan
Look, let's think about this.

Captain America is stronger than Wolverine when Wolvie has no healing factor. That is a fact. Cap doesn't need his shield if Wolvie doesn't have his claws anyway, so that's one more category down.

If the Captain were to dsiable Wolverine in some way, Wolverine could NOT heal back against it. That instantly takes him down a notch in durability. The Captain only has to worry about Logan's martial arts, and he is just the same in fighting skills. Plus, he is more controlled and doesn't lose temper straight off.

Steve wins.

I am.

^^

No, but I think that although cap is stronger, and much more battle savvy, they are on teh same level in martial arts. Wolverine has been training for a very very long time. Have you seen some of his feats?

Strength isn't too much of a factor in this fight as I see it. Nothing Captain America throws at Wolverine, unless it's his shield, can inflict the necessary amount of damage that is required to send Wolverine's healing factor into overdrive. Not with his hands. That gives Logan one more advantage along with his healing factor and adamantium bones. What damage can Captain America inflict? Now, combine that with Wolverine's fighting prowess. Yes, many writers have written Logan to be somewhat unstable with his temper but in his own series, he's hardly that way. He has the ability to calm himself and be as, if not more efficient a fighter than Captain America. Even in his rages, he's got heightened senses that far outmatch Captain America. He's only human.

i think wolverine would win

Originally posted by Etrigan
Look, let's think about this.

Captain America is stronger than Wolverine when Wolvie has no healing factor. That is a fact. Cap doesn't need his shield if Wolvie doesn't have his claws anyway, so that's one more category down.

If the Captain were to dsiable Wolverine in some way, Wolverine could NOT heal back against it. That instantly takes him down a notch in durability. The Captain only has to worry about Logan's martial arts, and he is just the same in fighting skills. Plus, he is more controlled and doesn't lose temper straight off.

Steve wins.

😑

Just to clear things up: in this fight (as set up by Batdude123) Wolverine doesn't have his healing factor, adamantium skeleton or claws and Captain America doesn't have his shield, right?

Originally posted by batdude123
For this fight, Wolverine can't use his claws and Captain America can't use his shield. This is just a straight up fist fight. Who would win?

😐

Originally posted by batdude123
Yes, that's a good idea. Wolverine's healing factor AND his adamantium bones are taken away from him as well. Now who wins?

😐

Originally posted by batdude123
Yes, that's a good idea. Wolverine's healing factor AND his adamantium bones are taken away from him as well. Now who wins?

^

Have there been any more changes?

I'm sure there will be. Maybe next they'll take away Wolverine's sense of direction..

take away his penis too!

Originally posted by TheKahn
^

Have there been any more changes?

Originally posted by Rick/Genis
take away his penis too!

Fine, Wolverine fights this w/o a penis as well. He's also castrated. 😆 No, but seriously, this is how it stands:

Wolverine:
No healing factor
No adamantium
No claws

Cap:
No shield

The reason I decided to have Cap keep his SSS, is because without it, he'd turn back into wimpy little Steve Rogers again.

Originally posted by Ritoshi
Take away caps super soilder thingy

Why don't we take both their powers away , any skill's and training , their weapons , their clothes and shove them in a pit to fight.

That seems to be the only way people will accept a fight between these two....

Originally posted by grey fox
Why don't we take both their powers away , any skill's and training , their weapons , their clothes and shove them in a pit to fight.

That seems to be the only way people will accept a fight between these two....

but I see ur piont

Why don't we take off their skin as well? Oh... and take out their bones! This is a purely muscle match, guys...

Originally posted by Rick/Genis
Why don't we take off their skin as well? Oh... and take out their bones! This is a purely muscle match guys...

Hell why don't we just rip them apart and see who makes the biggest mess ?

Originally posted by grey fox
Hell why don't we just rip them apart and see who makes the biggest mess ?

Caps bigger... but wolverine has the healing factor so he can bleed indefinitely.

Wolvy takes this