Rogue vs Hawkgirl

Well...

A single punch knocks HG head off.

Rogue should win (either current or classic), imo. Classic would have a rather impressive strength/durability advantage, and current would have more versatility if full advantage is taken of Sunfire's powers.

Rogue.

Rogue

I'm in agreement. Rogue would destroy her! Even if Hawk Girl got a few free shots it, I think Rogue still takes her easily. If worse came to worse, which in this fight it wouldn't, Rogue could slip the gloves off and drain her, as long as it wouldn't have some sort of wierd effect on Thanagarian's.

Gloves don't need to come off here. Rogue fries her

Mmmmm fried hawkgirl....

How do you like your hawkgirl, extra crispy or pulverised?

Rogue (current or classic) puts a serious hurting on her.