Windu´s Death

Started by King Jedi8 pages

If there isn't some kind of story or twist involving Mace then why is he there? I don't think he's there just so Yoda has someone to talk to. There has to be something else.

hes there to be a part of the jedi council, its not like hes gonna do anything bad...he cant, he gets killed

Bad guys don't get killed? There are lots of things that point towards Mace being bad.

bad guys get killed, he just doesnt have enough time to turn evil...and what points to him being bad??

I'll tell you tommorow. I need to find Lucas quotes on it.

GL made a comment on him being bad?
or you just refer to the interview were he says someone in the JC knows more then (s)he says?

go to:
www.starwars.com or www.lucasarts.com
ill check out lucasarts later (i hope thats the right website, im not quite sure because its saved on my favorites list an im not at my house)

Mace is there because GL has always wanted that character in Star Wars and yes, simply because he needed a conversational foil for Yoda. So the idea that Mace has to be bad or else he is pointless does not seem to carry; he's no more pointless than, say, Wedge was. Not all characters have to be 100% vital.

thank you...see? hes not bad, hes pointless

that's... nice

Wedge was a minor character who was in one scene in all three movies. Mace is a major charcter who's involed in the PT's main plot points. There is a difference.

Mace does nothing in the PT that can't be done by someone else. Storywise, it would probably be better if Yoda confided in Obi-Wan or the entire JC.

Mace has been set up as an important character and he has to go somewhere. Or whats the point? He's good, then he gets killed? That's it? If that happens then he's the most boring main character in all of Star Wars.

Yes Lucas said that in TPM, someone on the JC knew what was going on and that the Sith returned. Then we have Sam Jackson saying "everyone is second to Yoda. We're all struggling to be as good as him. Yoda is incorruptable". Suggesting that every other Jedi, including Mace, was curruptable. He's said that a few times.

Nah, we've been thropugh that a few times and it doesn't stand up- if Mace is revealed as a traitor now it would just be a pointless twist for its own sake; far more pointless than his character as it stands.

Well, I have no problem with him as it is, and I am sorry you do. But I am pretty sure he is what wesee him as- a heroic good guy who is going to go down. After all, it's nice to have at least one MAJOR Jedi that we are upset to see die, rather than all those background ones we do not care about.

Obi-Wan would have been no good as a foil for Yoda as he would be doing the main plot and addressing the whole JC would not have fitted the personal nature of the conversations in AOTC.

yup..i'm not partial on mace swinging side either. He will most probably die...how, and by whom.....and to see how Yoda gets back to dagobah...a defeat perhaps..could it be?

Originally posted by Dexx
He will most probably die

already confirmed

he will die!! all jedi cept for obi and yoda die!

u mean xept for luke..and the following generation.

It's a big galaxy so I'm not certain that ALL the jedi die

canon speaking... they die

Well maybe Mace isn't a traitor or maybe he isn't bad but I think there has to be some kind of developement with his charcter in Ep3. Right now I think he's pretty dull.

HEY!!! KJ's back. Welcome, dude!

Yeah, he's pretty dull. I still hope he gets killed in EP3.