What If Thread

For those keen on Japanese history, how do you suppose the future of Japan would have changed had Oda Nobunaga survived and flourished?

For those who are more keen on European history, how do you suppose the west would have changed had the Roman Empire not fallen?

Try and be as specific as possible, and feel free to speculate -heavily-.

I prefer WW2 what if discussions. 😉

Make your own thread then. "What If, WWII". Should be a hit.

OK

Hmm, for the first one, I can't really say. It's possible that Japan could have ended up as a more united country than it would have been if otherwise, but hmm...

For the second one, I'd need a little more information. Did it stave off all of the barbarian hordes? Did the west and east stay united?

Originally posted by Swirly Girl
Hmm, for the first one, I can't really say. It's possible that Japan could have ended up as a more united country than it would have been if otherwise, but hmm...

For the second one, I'd need a little more information. Did it stave off all of the barbarian hordes? Did the west and east stay united?

Yeah, Commodus was just an egomaniacal despot.

Now, if Nobunaga had survived, Japan would've likely seen a vicious and despotic shogunate for longer than if Tokugawa and Toyotomi hadn't started their civil war.

I was thinking more about the ramifications for Oda being pro-western and pro-modern world.

I doubt Japan would survive his rule long enough to modernize

Originally posted by Janus Marius
Run with the idea that the Roman Empire remained strong centrally, and that the office of emperor was eventually bound by laws so that the emperor could be disposed if he were an idiot like say, Commodus.

What if? Hitler was born earlier and became Emperor but still held his beliefs? OR What if the Roman Empire developed electricity?

Yeah...you gotta love fiction!

I think we'd still be speaking Latin! shock

😂 Hindsight and What If should be Illegal when talking about history.

Originally posted by Janus Marius
Run with the idea that the Roman Empire remained strong centrally, and that the office of emperor was eventually bound by laws so that the emperor could be disposed if he were an idiot like say, Commodus.

More technological advances maybe? I kinda think if Rome had survived there wouldn't have been a dark age; or at least it would have been much smaller. imo...

Oh and modern day Italy(if there would be one; maybe would be called by another name) would end up with some nice land. Think about how different Catholicisim could have been too.

Originally posted by Janus Marius
For those who are more keen on European history, how do you suppose the west would have changed had the Roman Empire not fallen?

this has always struck me as an interesting question. Certainly the fall of teh Roman empire didn't do too much to effect the spread of christianity, but what people in certain groups always want to say is that the fall of teh Roman empire came about because of their inherent divious behavior. But, it was ultimately christianity that led to teh fall of the Roman empire.

What if an army of Daleks killed Ceaser, or fourteen sillion people where born in the Hills of Rome?

RUBBISH! Thats what this thread is!

What if Hannibal had decided to seige Rome and didnt give the Romans to regroup after decimating its armed forces at Cannae?

What if Napoleon exploited his element of surprise in Waterloo more effectively?

What if the Mongol horde continued its march into Western Europe?

Originally posted by Janus Marius
For those keen on Japanese history, how do you suppose the future of Japan would have changed had Oda Nobunaga survived and flourished?

For those who are more keen on European history, how do you suppose the west would have changed had the Roman Empire not fallen?

Try and be as specific as possible, and feel free to speculate -heavily-.

Not keen on Japanese History, so I can't pretend I'm an expert.

As far as Roman Empire goes - perhaps the geography of what we know as ''Europe'' would be very different.
Perhaps we would all be 'Romans' right now, and a major power in the world.
Perhaps Native Americans would still be where they are, or perhaps we would have invaded America and made a second Rome there.

And while all this is happening Greece would be the most bitter country in the world.

Empire would have eventually fallen though. All Empires do.

Doubt the romans would have kept it together for another 2000 years.

Originally posted by lil bitchiness
Not keen on Japanese History, so I can't pretend I'm an expert.

Nah, don't say that, believe in yourself...

LoL, at uni they'll make firewood of that way of thinking B