Cyborg Darth Maul vs. General Greivous

Started by Razielim5 pages

His force potential was drastically low? Please.

At the age of 22 he was ripping up Jedi Masters and some of the best duelists in the Order.

And he could Force choke.

Originally posted by DePWNZOR
Maul is really stupid, and extremely overconfident. His force potential was lowered drastically too, so he couldn't force choke. Grievous wins.

any more baseless accusations and you will be shunned!

Pretty much...

I don't get the whole 'losing limbs and body parts lowers your power and potential!' thing. Vader seemed pretty freaking powerful even after he got hacked up.

Originally posted by Captain REX
Pretty much...

I don't get the whole 'losing limbs and body parts lowers your power and potential!' thing. Vader seemed pretty freaking powerful even after he got hacked up.

true. with vader it slowed him down a little physically. possibly letting focus more on the dark side?

but with maul, it made him faster and stronger. and he still used the dark side.

starwars

Seriously, Maul looked like a tank when he was running. I would not want THAT running straight towards me...

i would have crapped myself.

I doubt Owen wanted another one on one shot with Maul after he smacked him with his own rifle, and broke it across his face.

Originally posted by Captain REX
I don't get the whole 'losing limbs and body parts lowers your power and potential!' thing.

An individuals power and potential to wield the Force is determined by their midi-chlorian count. Anakin had the highest ever reading (having been created through manipulation of the Force) so it's not surprizing that he was the most powerfull Jedi (just not necessarily the most skilled Jedi...) When a person is maimed as Anakin (or Maul for that matter) was, then they lose a signifigant percentage of their midi-chlorian count, (due to missing body parts) so their ability to wield the force is diminished.

Originally posted by Captain REX
Vader seemed pretty freaking powerful even after he got hacked up.

Are you serious? Consider the 'athletic prowess' displayed by Vader in ANH, ESB and RotJ, and compare it to Anakin in his prime (and with all his body parts) in AotC and RotS. There is no comparison to the power he is able to wield in a duel, or the acrobatics that he is able to perfom before he was maimed. Darth Vader, as he appeared in ANH, ESB and RotJ, is a shadow of his former self.

An individuals power and potential to wield the Force is determined by their midi-chlorian count. Anakin had the highest ever reading (having been created through manipulation of the Force) so it's not surprizing that he was the most powerfull Jedi (just not necessarily the most skilled Jedi...) When a person is maimed as Anakin (or Maul for that matter) was, then they lose a signifigant percentage of their midi-chlorian count, (due to missing body parts) so their ability to wield the force is diminished.

I'd just like to note that Vader lost less than half of his body. Going by Midichlorians, he would have lost less than half of his potential.

And I'd hardly called AotC Anakin to be anywhere near his prime. Mecha Vader is 80% as powerful as a superior version of Palpatine, and he has stomped on many PT Jedi before. No doubt in my mind Mecha Vader > AotC Anny

Hell, it can be argued that RotS Anakin is the strongest Jedi of the PT era, assuming his heads on properly of course.

Not only that, the Force is something beyond physical limitations, according to Yoda in ESB. I think the whole concept of Midichlorians to be childish. Well, that's just me.

i agree. Midichlorians just determine how intune with the force you are. like Qui-gon said, "They are constantly speaking to us, telling us the will of the Force."

So, how I see it: the more midichlorians, the more potential and better conection ( like a telephone) to the force. Vader is so powerful because of his potential, training, and will. Surviving Mustafar is testament to that.

you all forget that maul would have his entire upper body his legs are hardly a hinderence, he got fixed by geonosians and so did grievouse so what makes you think he isnt as flexible as grievouse, plus maul can still use the force, in saboteur and shadow both he battled super human droids for hours on end, plus he dropped the black sun, a notorious bounty hunter and Yanth the hutt's entire army of guards. Maul also took out two different fuel companies in saboteur!

I'd just like to note that Vader lost less than half of his body. Going by Midichlorians, he would have lost less than half of his potential.

No, where did you ever get the idea that he lost less than 1/2 his body? In the ANH AC, Lucas says Vader lost half his body, exactly. He's talking about the fight and why it's pretty slow and stuff when in ROTS Obi and Vader are fighting super fast. He says it's slow because it's between someone who is half machine and someone who is old.

he lost his arms and legs thats hardly half his body considering all ligaments were below the knees/elbows

Don't forget that the rest of him was cooked like bacon.

...

Originally posted by Darth Vious
Are you serious? Consider the 'athletic prowess' displayed by Vader in ANH, ESB and RotJ, and compare it to Anakin in his prime (and with all his body parts) in AotC and RotS. There is no comparison to the power he is able to wield in a duel, or the acrobatics that he is able to perfom before he was maimed. Darth Vader, as he appeared in ANH, ESB and RotJ, is a shadow of his former self.

That is not power, that is agility. Feats that Vader manages to pull off with the Force are worthy of Master Yoda, many of them very early on after ROTS. For example, his brutally bashing Roan Shryne to death with a wooden catwalk that he basically ripped apart with significant ease, once he had really gotten the hang of the Dark Side. He crushes the Dark Woman, a Jedi who exhibited bizarre abilities and great power, with very little difficulty, though she presents some problems for him in the beginning of the duel...not the end, though. He holds a massive tree over her and drops it...

His use of the Force is power. Using it in agile moves isn't really a very good measure of power.

Originally posted by Captain REX
Don't forget that the rest of him was cooked like bacon.

...

That is not power, that is agility. Feats that Vader manages to pull off with the Force are worthy of Master Yoda, many of them very early on after ROTS. For example, his brutally bashing Roan Shryne to death with a wooden catwalk that he basically ripped apart with significant ease, once he had really gotten the hang of the Dark Side. He crushes the Dark Woman, a Jedi who exhibited bizarre abilities and great power, with very little difficulty, though she presents some problems for him in the beginning of the duel...not the end, though. He holds a massive tree over her and drops it...

His use of the Force is power. Using it in agile moves isn't really a very good measure of power.

I hated when he killed the Dark Woman...

Must be said, that story is technically non-canon due to the fact that Tales is disputed due to the random stories they throw in that usually are like 'wtf? that can't be right...'

I thought it was a great fight, myself. Sad and heartless, but a great duel.

The hell? There's a cyborg Maul now? Wonderful.

Originally posted by Motoko Sama
I doubt Owen wanted another one on one shot with Maul after he smacked him with his own rifle, and broke it across his face.

is this the same owen that luke was given to?, oh and im considering reading the new vader book like right after ROTS, any positive or negative comments?

Originally posted by Razielim

Anywho, here are the scans from Maul vs Ben.

Originally posted by DarthMaul9123
is this the same owen that luke was given to?, oh and im considering reading the new vader book like right after ROTS, any positive or negative comments?

yes.

and i loved the Dark Woman duel.
the analogy between the flower species and the jedi was sweet.