Poll
17%
83%
OF Course Castle has a chance. Castle is extremely skilled h2h(He has mastered ninjitsu,Hwarangdo,Chin Na and Shorin-Ryu to name a few.That is excluding the additional h2h training from the seals and marines).Castle could take DD 7/10. It would be tough but Castle has the experience.He is known to have killed nearly a dozen men at a time, not to mention the thousands of kills he has had!DD Lacks the killer instinct.Also Castle engages in a brutal regemen of calistenics, katas and firing range practice daily.He trains while DD is doing his lawyer thing.Castle is an exceptional knife fighter as well!Castle definitely has the upper hand!
Back in the day Punisher smacked around Daredevil a couple of times. He was using guns, but when Daredevil brought it close quarters Frank had no problem keeping up and even gaining the upper hand. It was even in Daredevil's own book. These days DD's fighting ability is unrealistic and rediculous. Without guns Castle would go down in a matter of minutes, even with grenades and knives.