Well well well, here we are.
S.S.
+Background, color and brushing are nice.
- Render, the placementof the render was good but could have used more of it.
+Text, the text placement and color matching are on the money.
Taft
+Background is nicely blended together and color scheme is nice.
+Render, the render placement is good and so is the way you used most of it.
-Text, while text is simple and nice, it could have been another kind of font blended into the sig.
This was tough, even though S.S' sig pops out at you, I can't deny taft has a very simple but very well done sig.
Outcome- Tie.