Originally posted by Spartan005
Ok... I agree with you that Taylor is a LOT more fun to watch, but Katherine has such a better voice then him its just ridiculous...
wow...are we listening to the same McPhee here?lol.
Simon said it best, "You think you are as good as Whitney Houston. Your Not."
She has a very unpleasant, cold voice. She just sings...there's no warmth, depth or emotion there. That is the biggest asset Taylor, amidst all his goofyness has. 馃槉
Originally posted by Ladyluck
Taylor's musical calibur?! Are you ****ing serious?! The only thing that makes him fun to watch is the fact that he looks like an idiot when he runs around on the stage. He has no talent. Anyone can do what he's doing.American Idol is lame. It's just a huge popularity contest.
Replace "he" with "anyone ever on that show" and you're right.
Originally posted by Punkyhermy
Did you not see him perform 'you are so beautiful to me'?!If that's not talent...then I don't know who on the show is talented really.
And yes. It is...*nods* 馃槵
No one is. Anyone with training can do what they're doing.
Originally posted by Punkyhermy
wow...are we listening to the same McPhee here?lol.Simon said it best, "You think you are as good as Whitney Houston. Your Not."
She has a very unpleasant, [B]cold
voice. She just sings...there's no warmth, depth or emotion there. That is the biggest asset Taylor, amidst all his goofyness has. 馃槉 [/B]
Maybe we're not... (this sounds gay馃槅 but...) did you hear her sing Over the Rainbow???
Originally posted by Ladyluck
He goes off key all the time.No one on that show is ever talented, and when someone actually is, they get voted off because people don't care about talent and musical ability. All they care about is whether they give a good performance or not, and that's the only reason why Taylor is still on.
True. We saw that earlier this season when Mandisa, Paris and Lisa got booted off. And the fact that McPhee made this far just proves your point, yes. 馃槵
But here's the thing, being s good singer is really more than just about having a good singing voice. Being a performer is what completes the singer. You can't just be singer. You have to be the star too.And that Taylor is.
Originally posted by Punkyhermy
True. We saw that earlier this season when Mandisa, Paris and Lisa got booted off. And the fact that McPhee made this far just proves your point, yes. 馃槵But here's the thing, being s good singer is really more than just about having a good singing voice. Being a performer is what completes the singer. You can't just be singer. You have to be the star too.And that Taylor is.
I agree with about the whole being a good singer as well as a good performer but Talyor isn't a good singer! If you're going to have one without the other, you're better off at least being talented and having a good voice. The only thing Taylor has going for him is the fact that he's entertaining because he runs around like an idiot. He's far from being talented.
Originally posted by Captain REX
****in ace jordan 馃槀
a. I like Kelly Clarkson, she has talent and she was made by American Idol.
b. I didn't like Taylor's performance at all today, and it's the only one I've ever seen of his.
c. I like the song Kat chose, but she wasn't all that good either, try hard anyone.
d. I've seen in the whole time American Idol's been on tv, maybe like 10 episodes, ever.
I love the fact that I point out something very true and it's ignored (the fact that anyone with training can do what the people on that show can do).
Why do you people buy into that crap? They're untalented singers who will get contracts handed to them for doing nothing whatsoever and will then go on to flood MTV with even MORE shit music. Boy ain't that great.
Originally posted by Ladyluck
I agree with about the whole being a good singer as well as a good performer but Talyor isn't a good singer! If you're going to have one without the other, you're better off at least being talented and having a good voice. The only thing Taylor has going for him is the fact that he's entertaining because he runs around like an idiot. He's far from being talented.
Kat never struck me as one having talent either. She made it this far because she is pretty. Guys vote to see her on stage. And finally she shared the stage with Taylor because having her againts him was more commerically successful than having Chris who deserved to be there. Girl. vs. guy thing made it a lot more interesting...*shrugs*
Originally posted by Lana
I love the fact that I point out something very true and it's ignored (the fact that anyone with training can do what the people on that show can do).Why do you people buy into that crap? They're untalented singers who will get contracts handed to them for doing nothing whatsoever and will then go on to flood MTV with even MORE shit music. Boy ain't that great.
I agree with you. 馃槢
Originally posted by Ladyluck
I thought she did a great job on that song but unfortunately it was one of her only good performances.
I actually think that she's a great singer... but there's something I don't like about her personality. She just seems so damn stuck up
Originally posted by MASTERdeBATER
And remember when you buy an album you only listen to the artist