When has this ever been said in the movies?

Started by d-fly_girl0083 pages
d-fly_girl008 Bel Fan Club President

no offence, but i am using im language so...

hpfanizzledizzl Sock Hunter

I'm aware. But this isn't Instant Messageing. It's a forum. Forums (surprisingly enough) are designed for intellegent conversation. Not meaningless unfathomable babble.

d-fly_girl008 Bel Fan Club President

wow, you have a big vocabulary...

hpfanizzledizzl Sock Hunter

Thank you.

The Phantom Angel of Music

Ok, I KNOW ITS IN THE BOOK! I'M TALKING MOVIE! I want a quote from the movie. Got one? Go ahead, go search. I have time. NEVER HAS IT BEEN SAID IN THE MOVIE!

hpfanizzledizzl Sock Hunter

Phantom, please no yelling.

d-fly_girl008 Bel Fan Club President

i'm not going to quote the movie when knowing it's in the book should be enough

hpfanizzledizzl Sock Hunter

But he's talking about them movie. This thread is about the movie...not the book. Therefore, we (for the sake of greater knowledge) will pretend we never read the books, and only saw the movies.

d-fly_girl008 Bel Fan Club President

but why???

The Phantom Angel of Music

... Because that is the point of this thread! How can people who never read the books put the connections together. I know its in the books, but they never said it in the movie. I find it a mistake.

d-fly_girl008 Bel Fan Club President

i thought they did say it in the movie, when sirius was talking to harry???

hpfanizzledizzl Sock Hunter

Because it's an original thread. If you ever come up with an original thread, we will respect your idea. So respect his ideas, try to give/obtain knowledge, and create an ORIGINAL thread of your own.

The Phantom Angel of Music

Originally posted by d-fly_girl008
i thought they did say it in the movie, when sirius was talking to harry???
When? They have spken to each other several times. Never has he said who they are. He never said he was Padfoot, Lupin was Moony, or James was Prongs. Niether did theys say James was an animagus. So really, in the movies, Harry is pretty much blind of a lot of things of his father.

d-fly_girl008 Bel Fan Club President

i'm sorry i thought it said it in the movie, my mistake

The Phantom Angel of Music

Originally posted by d-fly_girl008
i'm sorry i thought it said it in the movie, my mistake
Tis alright. This is why I opened the thread, to see if anyone has proof that it has been said. I will shut up with proof that it has been said. (or watch the movie again and see it has been said. But I swear it hasn't!)

nehaa .Confused.

watch the movie again and make sure you watch it properly because it has been mentioned I am 100per.sure

TheKingofKINGS! Sock Hunter

Originally posted by nehaa
watch the movie again and make sure you watch it properly because it has been mentioned I am 100per.sure
It hasn't, you fail.

Diamonds I'm Special.

Originally posted by d-fly_girl008
no offence, but it is just a little cat room, so no need to be that way, and i just asked if they were clueless, i never said they were, and it kind of is really obvious so...
KMC is little? I think not 😐 KMC most likely has the biggest Harry Potter forum on the net (not counting forums made specifically for Potter). Not everyone who watches the movies have read the books. Most of the people I know have seen the movies but haven't read the books.
But Phamtom, I don't really think most of them notice or care. At least not my friends anyway.

dondo Junior Member

.....looking at the previous page...evryone was saying harrys patronus is a deer....which it is clealy not it is a "Stag".... which throws out the obviousness of the name prongs...because of the antlers...mentioned by d-flygirl

The Phantom Angel of Music

Originally posted by dondo
.....looking at the previous page...evryone was saying harrys patronus is a deer....which it is clealy not it is a "Stag".... which throws out the obviousness of the name prongs...because of the antlers...mentioned by d-flygirl
Seriously, do people sit and watch the movie to know what prongs are, what padfoots are, or why it is Lupin is Moony. Seriously, you have to think about it after watching the movies to get it if you never read the books. Just because you guys get it like that doesn't mean other people will. Why? Because not everyone has read the books. Case closed. They didn't announce it, they should've announced it for all the people who don't read, but didn't and thus I am giving them a lower rating for carelessness for viewers.