Thorinn:
+ COLOR SCHEME
[Null] Text is iffy
-lack of geometry
-border? If its there, its weak.
-size
Aurora:
+ GEOMETRY
[null] color schemes ok, but could be much better
[null] text
-gif edges suck
-background is nostaligic, but relatively underdeveloped
Niehter of you got both gemoetry and color imo. I have to give this one to Aurora (though might I add barely). Thorinn's color kicked 😖, but the tiny detail (Thorinn) I wish you had done one a bit larger and used more of the render. That might have netted you the victory. I think your fit the criteria well (for future reference).
Winner: Aurora
but WATCH YOUR GIF EDGES!!!!😠
But good job both and thank you both for attempting to work within my arbitrary criteria.