darth maul vs genaral greivus

Started by PurpleSaber4 pages

I think Maul would win. You are forgetting that he defeated Qui-Gon who was a powerful Jedi Master who would have been on the council had he not defied them.

Teras Kasi. Force Choke, Force Push, The ability to decapatate some of the most powerful commanders in the black sun organization, he has been through worse(i just finished reading the maul comics), and finally if Rots Obiwan can beat GG then TPM obiwan and Qui gon could do the same, especially as a team.

In short. Maul would win.

Originally posted by PurpleSaber
I think Maul would win. You are forgetting that he defeated Qui-Gon who was a powerful Jedi Master who would have been on the council had he not defied them.

And Grievous has tooled members of the Council. You are forgetting that Maul had trouble with an enraged padawan Obi-Wan (though I still think Maul > TPM Obi).

Teras Kasi.

An offensive Force power? I think not.

It's a martial art.

Force Choke, Force Push,

Force pushes obviously aren't the end of Grievous as I've stated. Did ROTS Obi-Wan's force push kill Grievous? Was he annihilated by it?

The ability to decapatate some of the most powerful commanders in the black sun organization,

Force sensitives? No. Wow Maul, you managed to kill some Black Sun, whereas Grievous has fought the Republic soldiers, and numerous Jedi. Maul, you fought a Nightsister who had a small grasp over the Darkside! Wow Maul - You're the man now!

How many Jedi has Maul faced again? How many did Maul kill again?

he has been through worse(i just finished reading the maul comics),

"Through worse" what? Have you read Grievous' comics?

and finally if Rots Obiwan can beat GG then TPM obiwan and Qui gon could do the same, especially as a team.

Right. That makes sense that two Ataru practinors can contend with Grievous. ROTS Obi-Wan is a Soresu master. TPM Obi-Wan practices Ataru. Grievous has tooled padawans, Jedi masters, and Jedi Knights - sometimes even facing more than one at once. He can defeat TPM Ob-Wan and Qui-Gon.

In short. Maul would win.

In short, no.

In Short, tell me why anything of that sort wouldn't work on GG, Choke would be all it takes...END OF THE FAIRY TALE

Been done a hundred (exaggeration) times before. it'd be close but I go with... Maul, probably, just cause, well, Kenobi really didn't have a ton of trouble with Grievous until he lost his lightsaber. So unless Maul loses his lightsaber he could probably beat Grievous, too, though it wouldn't be easy. Maul's also got the advantage of the Force.

Thank you...(glances at sig) goosh goosh goosh.... you people.

Originally posted by Legion_of_Maul
In Short, tell me why anything of that sort wouldn't work on GG, Choke would be all it takes...END OF THE FAIRY TALE

Hm, because a force push has been shown to only throw Grievous back. Whoa, that works - it'll be the end of Grievous, I mean Obi-Wan killed him right then and there. Let's say Maul drops into the Riding Bantha stance of Teräs Käsi, Grievous is definitely faster than Maul - Maul's arms and legs are severed.

And the rest of what you posted was addressed and really holds no relevance to his offensive Force powers.

Kenobi really didn't have a ton of trouble with Grievous until he lost his lightsaber.

And I suppose Maul is somehow a Soresu master? A defensive lightsaber form, which is another good reason as to why ROTS Obi-Wan won. Maul uses Juyo, and even with his Juyo his lightsaber was cut in half by an enraged padawan who uses Ataru.

And I suppose Maul would beat ROTS Obi-Wan then? No, he wouldn't. So don't compare Maul to Obi-Wan.

GG throws 16 attacks a second. The second Maul throws his hand out for a push or (i am not sure he can even do it) choke he will be missing a limb. great.

he can force choke, in saboteur he choked 3 people at the same time, one of them had armour around his neck.
maul could also do what Mace windu did and crush his suit, or pop his inards

Personally I think that the Count would come in and pwn them both 😛

Anyways it would be an extremely close fight. However GG would win. Mauls force abilities would help but they are not as big a deal as you are making them out to be. GG was force crushed by Mace Windu, one of the greatest force users of the era, and GG escaped with only a cough. And I think it is fair to say that Windu is a better force user than Maul. Then add in the fact that Maul will not have a chance to use the force with GG 4 sabres coming at him at once. And in a pure lightsaber duel Maul would simply get overwhelmed with all the blades coming at him at once. Even if he did stand a chance, GG would just change his style to counter Mauls. As good as Maul is, he will not be able to beat the killing machine that is Greivous.

Grievous has no range, so all Maul has to do is keep his distance and pull off some stuff with telekinesis.

Originally posted by Count Kent
Grievous has no range, so all Maul has to do is keep his distance and pull off some stuff with telekinesis.

True. But Greivous is no slouch. He is fast and can jump pretty large distances. So Maul will only be able to inflict minimal damage if any by the time GG catches up with him.

Originally posted by darthsith19
Kenobi really didn't have a ton of trouble with Grievous until he lost his lightsaber.

When Obi-Wan fought Grievous, Grievous had been injured/damaged by Mace's Force choke. In Clone Wars, he was able to take on five trained Jedi using only two lightsabers (he didn't even need to detatch his arms) When he faced Obi-Wan, he needed to detatch his arms and use four lightsabers.
Maul can block, but not that many blades. As he was in RotS, Grievous would win (albeit with some resistance from Maul) As he was in CW, Grievous would be so fast, Maul wouldn't stand a chance.

What's going on here? Both Rampant and Vious made a good point for a change?

Originally posted by Motoko Sama
What's going on here? Both Rampant and Vious made a good point for a change?

I always make a good point, you just don't always agree with it 😉

why would Maul even try a choke, Grievous doesn't need to breathe..Grievous has killed council members, too. Pablo Jill and Adi Gallia...both skilled Jedi

Originally posted by Lightsnake
why would Maul even try a choke, Grievous doesn't need to breathe..

If he doesn't need to breathe, why does he cough and wheeze following Mace's Force choke? The Force was the one thing Grievous was really vulnerable to (untill it damaged him enough to impair his function)

He relies on the machines to breathe for him, like Vader...Mace didn't try to choke him, he tried to crush his chest and damaged both Grievous's remaining organs and machines.

bull.... when obiwan pulled open his chesy you saw lungs and they were moving, and force choke would just stop the machines, DUH, you think a skilled asassin wouldn't know how to take grievous down?

Which is why Grievous dispatched Durge and Asajj Ventress at the same time? And yes...that's why the machines do the work FOR Grievous, much liuke they did with Anakin