Ok, this was a hard one, both were pretty crappy so...
Kai Lein: I'm not going to cut you slack just because the render was all screwed up. I liked how you gave it an overall "gansta" sorta look it worked well with the render. I also liked how you blended the pink by using red. It would of been better if you used text though. And I'm going to have to take off points for not being a good competitor. Also, take more time on your sigs! No bonus.
Vinny: There is something about your sig that rubs me the wrong way. The colour didn't go too well. I liked the text, and how you used more of the render in the sig. The background wasn't very impressive. Over all it lacked creativity. It didn't look like you tried at all. 😛 And it looked too simple for my taste. Good job on the bonus. 😂
I am tempted to call it a tie, but I'm not a fan of them so...
Winner: Kai Lein
Good job to both of you. I know it was a shitty render, but it wouldn't of been much of a challenge if it wasn't. 😛