A.D.Skinner vs. Thorinn

99% of the duels done here wouldn't be usable for actual sigs (either size requirements or....questionable content), and stuff like this has been done before. It's fine.

And just to be totally random, my phone is growling.

*grrrrooowwl*

Originally posted by DigiMark007
I like that Alliance is uber-creative with his requirements, but judges should probably check with the participants before doing anything too outlandish.

I like a good challenge, and I have been dueling for some time now, so I know what possiblilities there are.

I think Alliance made a good challenge for us ( even though I haven't posted an entry yet )!

I don't think it necessary for the Judge to check with the participants first...if that was the case, then all the duels would be easy! ✅

Originally posted by A.D. Skinner
I don't think it necessary for the Judge to check with the participants first...if that was the case, then all the duels would be easy! ✅

I agree with more with Digi. I don't think participants should expect a standard 450x150, 60kb sig, but anything larger than 500 px might warrant a checking.

Some renders deserve that kind of space.

But I'm glad you guys like my ideas 😄

I gave up trying to make it a mech signature. weep

cool 🙂

Entry

cool 🙂

*awaits judgement*

Has this duel been forgotten?

No 😛

Thorinn:
👆👆color scheme
👆Nice placement of render
👆additional elements
😐Text (Its ok, but Thorinn is not well integrated
👇 integration of render into background (make it seel lik eit belongs! (tonally etc))

ADS:

👆👆Giving the render a new feel
👆 colors, but you somewhat broke this with the swirls
😐 background (nice but repetative)
😐 text (thorinn is nice and creative, precise is well...😐)
😐 swirls. They are nice, but stand rejected in the corner, involving them in the action would be nice)

Winner: Thorin.

Why: I really like the color shceme ad the idea of the sig, but the render was not very well integrated. It was not a clear choice.

What lost it for ADS was the disconeect between his additonial elements (some of the text and the poor abandoned swirls) and the render. The render was very well integrated and he gave the render a very childish feel which was talented and createive, keeping him in the game.

GD ALL! I hope you enjoyed yoursleves and at least I was pleased! 😄

Thanks for the feedback..I will keep that in mind if I ever choose you to judge my duels again.

Thorinn...I really liked your sig, and I feel that the best sig won in the end. I would always be willing for a rematch at a later date if you are up for it.

NP...as a judge I think its my primary responsibilty to justify my opinon....hopefully it helps you improve. But its only my opinion, take it for what its worth 🙂

w00t great duel.

Thanks Alliance.

And will do for another go around A.D.

cool!