Originally posted by Soujaboy
"He has a healing factor"(Hulk fans)"He's immortal because of his healing factor"(Hulk fans)
"You can't kill him because of his healing factor" (Hulk fans)
"He has unlimited strength"(Hulk fans)
"he says he's the strongest one there is, so he has to be"(Hulk fans)
"Hulk can defeat Juggernaut"
Wow. You are the king of straw man reasoning.
Originally posted by Darth_Erebus
I hate "what if" threads. What if Superman had the Phoenix force, what if Wolverine was class 100? Well, in comics they don't/aren't. Quit amping up (basically inventing) a character just because you always want them to win.
what about the what if comics they have powered chars down y cant we power them up (i do agree with u but in a diffrent way)
Originally posted by Sea King
yes it does cancel out magic but it has been said in the aquaman comics to heal mutations it does not say just physical mutation it may show it that way but their is also no evidence that he cant heal all forms of mutation show me that and i will stop with that argument
Give me the name of the comics where it states that Aquaman can heal natural mutations and I'll check it out.
I asked Lucid Lui(A huge Aquaman Fan and one of the few people responsible for the Aquaman respect thread, he said:
Originally posted by Lucid Lui
In the case of Black Manta it seems pretty clear that it was the hand undoing Neron's sorcery, which in turn reversed the mutation. It's never shown anything like the fine tuning of reversing a mutation in a mutant with telepathy, or powers that don't manifest in a physical way, so it's stupid to say that it could, for instance, cure Jean Grey of being a mutant. It should, in theory, be able to cure mutations that manifest physically, but it hasn't been shown to do so yet (and probably won't be) so you can't really say it could turn Beast back to normal.Yes, in all instance of him healing someone he's made contact.
The closest thing would be when he devolved The Shark with just his telepathy. The scans are in the respect thread.
Black Manta's mutation was derived from Neron's Dark Sorcery, so that feat is basically him reversing the socerey.
He uses his Telepathy to devolve The Sharks mind. And in doing so the shark returns to being a Tiger Shark.
So basically there are no feats where Aquaman can cure natural mutations. And if there are no feats then well he doesn't have that ability.
Until you can come up with another event where Aquaman uses his magic hand to cure a natural mutation, that argument is currently rendered obsolete.
(The scans are in the Aquaman respect thread)
Originally posted by ExodusCloak
Give me the name of the comics where it states that Aquaman can heal natural mutations and I'll check it out.
I asked Lucid Lui(A huge Aquaman Fan and one of the few people responsible for the Aquaman respect thread, he said:Black Manta's mutation was derived from Neron's Dark Sorcery, so that feat is basically him reversing the socerey.
He uses his Telepathy to devolve The Sharks mind. And in doing so the shark returns to being a Tiger Shark.
So basically there are no feats where Aquaman can cure natural mutations. And if there are no feats then well he doesn't have that ability.
Until you can come up with another event where Aquaman uses his magic hand to cure a natural mutation, that argument is currently rendered obsolete.
(The scans are in the Aquaman respect thread)
yes i know how lucid lui is but u seem to be over looking part of what he said witch is basicaly the same thing i said
"It should, in theory, be able to cure mutations that manifest physically, but it hasn't been shown to do so yet"
so yes it should be able to but has not been shown to so like i said show me real proof that it cant
Originally posted by Sea King
yes i know how lucid lui is but u seem to be over looking part of what he said witch is basicaly the same thing i said"It should, in theory, be able to cure mutations that manifest physically, but it hasn't been shown to do so yet"
so yes it should be able to but has not been shown to so like i said show me real proof that it cant
Okay so we've established that in theory he can only heal Physical Mutations derived from Magic then?
Didn't you read the bit after that?
"so you can't really say it could turn Beast back to normal."
So there's no evidence to support the theory that Aquaman can heal Beast.
As for the last bit, to win this discussion I don't need to prove that Aquaman can't. If he hasn't been shown to cure a natural mutation then he obviously can't. It's like saying in theory Jubes might be able to fly, prove that Jubilee can't use her abilities to fly. If she hasn't shown any feats where she's flown then obviously she can't fly.
Originally posted by ExodusCloak
Didn't you read the bit after that?[b] "so you can't really say it could turn Beast back to normal."
So there's no evidence to support the theory that Aquaman can heal Beast.
As for the last bit, to win this discussion I don't need to prove that Aquaman can't. If he hasn't been shown to cure a natural mutation then he obviously can't. It's like saying, prove that Jubilee can't use her abilities to fly. If she hasn't shown any feats where she's flown then obviously she can't fly. [/B]
the abscents of prove is not the prove of abscents 😄
supes can just fly into the sun
hulks strength is unlimited
blodlusted ss can beat thanos
wolves healing factor will prevent it
jobber
superman is faster,so he wins
superman has more wilpower so he wins
hulk died from being impaled
hulk stopped juggernaut
hulk would stalemate juggernaut
superman caan beat anybody
if you saay that thanos wins your a fanboy
thanos didnt do it on his own power
supes could beat thanos
darkseid could beat thanos
thanos isnt strong
if you try to bring up thanoss feats, its pis.
odin would have killed thanos
odin wasnt trying
thanos was getting his ass kicked(which it was a stalemate until thanos overpowered gungir, and got shot back)
celestials are over galactus
galactus got beat by thor
in h2h thanos would lose to hulk
the list goes on and on
Originally posted by Sea King
the abscents of prove is not the prove of abscents 😄
So now Jubilee can fly, Wolverine can manifest the power cosmic, Angel can grow to 100 feet, Beast can burrow to the center of the earth, and Aquaman can heal mutations.
Because there is no evidence of them failing to?
Good logic, bud.
Originally posted by Soljerwell i dont think makeing fun of your self is a veary good logic
So now Jubilee can fly, Wolverine can manifest the power cosmic, Angel can grow to 100 feet, Beast can burrow to the center of the earth, and Aquaman can heal mutations.Because there is no evidence of them failing to?
Good logic, bud.
aquaman has been shown to heal mutations before now it was under certin conditions so it cant be said one way or another if he could heal all mutations or not
as for the guy saying aquaman always wins in arguments i gess if thats what you want to belive