Harry Potter 7 disscusion-I WANT YOUR OPINION ON THIS!

my friend and i were thinking for the 7th one that what if sirius came back as like a ghost or something like nearly headless nick. or how do peopel who die come back as ghosts? did jkr like explain that and i just forgot. i dont know but what do you guys think?

shes gonna explain that more in the 7th book. The only info on that is in the fifth book. Technically you have ot be afraid of death or have un finished dutied on Earth which we dont know that Sirius had any unfinished business. But i doubt that he was afraid o fdeath. But once again thats a mystery and the 7th book is the answer and unfortunately we won't get the answer until 7/7/07. bawling

the book doesnt get out until next summer!!!!!!! omg that is like forever away!!!!! awwww now i am really sad!

awww now im really depressed. but wait....if ghosts are people who are who died that were afraid to die.....then wont most people be ghosts? and yeah, (i was that friend).......i think sirius will come back. How? well i have absolutely no idea! 😉

I know the two way mirrors will be a great part in the story. It was Sirius's. I don't think he will turn out to be a ghost or human maybe a trapped spirit close to a ghost but not quite.

o yeah i forgot about the two mirrors in the 5th one. i was soo mad at the end of the 5th one after sirus died that harry could have easily talked to him! he would probably still be alive. anyway yeah i really hope that sirius does come back somehow! he was like one of my favorite characters!

two way mirrors??!! omg i have to read the 5th one again! i dont remember those!!! AHHHHH!!!

hahhah yeah but first you have to finish the 4th one! are you almost done with it???

no not yet. im kinda.....bored of it *the crowd gasps* (i am so ashamed)

well ohiluvhp you know my input i haelped come up with the theory but just to add to paliwal_ruppal snape does know about the ring because he helped dumbledore from dying after destroying it dumbledore says in the book so if snape really is loyal to voldy(as one of you put it lol) than voldy knows exactly what harry is up to also dumbledore did say that it was not wise to put a horcrux into a person or animal but if he didnt mean to do it than that explains it . maybe snape suspects something in harry that does remind him of voldy and that is the true reason that he hasnt tried to kill him. and what happens if harry kills voldemort after destroying the rest of the horcruxes than voldy will have to go into harry's body than what happens will someone else have to destroy harry (neville also worked out in the prophesy) or ron or hermione or will harry be able to control someone that evil inside him and/or kill himself all good questions (sorry that was a bit choppy lol)

i think harry being a horcrux is an excellent hypothesis
and i think there is excellent possibility its true!! great job!!! 🙂

i doubt sirius can come back as a ghost

I highly doubt Harry is a Horcrux. I mean Voldy is smart enough not to make a human a Horcrux! He can control Nagini thats why she's a Horcrux. Buy why would Voldy want to kill Harry if Harry has a part of Voldy in him. It's not logical.

Amazes me this hasn't been moved yet

i know!!! I was like wait this isn't fan fiction!

well its lasted...hasnt it?

sorry about the double post!

but..................................................i dono

It doesn't make sense because if harry kills the voldemort in his body, voldemort would go into harry's body, and he would be in pain and wouldn't be able to kill himself

thats true. but what if voldemort doesnt know part of him is inside harry?

thats a possibility, but i agree w/ iluvhp1_7 and cundiff11, unless voldy doesnt know about harry having a part of soul, then harry prolly isnt a horcrux..brings up the question they had(iluvhp and cundiff), why would he try to kill part of his soul?