Most of your threads are spite threads.
Why pit Skyfather-level characters against characters that at the most rank herald....?
Yeah, it's called a spite thread.
Replace CM with Shazam the Wizard and Superman with Steel in the Entropy Armour and you have an actual fight.
Ever wonder why most your threads last like three posts at most? It's because they're wildly imbalanced and not worth a lick of dog spit discussing as would Jubilee vs. Thor.
Make even battles worth discussing that people are capable of debating about and your threads won't be emptier than a church on Friday.