Apoclypse vs Martian Manhunter

Started by Priest5 pages
Originally posted by batdude123
RANGE OF POWER, illusions, shutting down minds, controlling their minds, etc.

i don't think apoc would be effected with a mind attack, someone said that professor X couldn't attack apoc's mind, and cable as well cant..
Apocalypse as well is a excellent telepath as well, which is why his mind can not be reached .

Originally posted by batdude123
RANGE OF POWER, illusions, shutting down minds, controlling their minds, etc.

Ok so it's pretty fair to say that range of power is just one of 4 powers you listed, we won't clutter the list anymore fo now.

So MM has shown a great power degree in one aspect of 4, you answered your own piece, MM displaying greater range doesn't nec make him a better Telepath, it simply means he can scan FARTHER then Charles. So it would seem we should be on the same page now, MM can scan farther but being as thats 1 of 4 doesn't make him a stronger telepath overall.

Originally posted by Priest
i don't think apoc would be effected with a mind attack, someone said that professor X couldn't attack apoc's mind, and cable as well cant..
Apocalypse as well is a excellent telepath as well, which is why his mind can not be reached .

Even so, Martian Manhunter has a slew of other powers that he would use to kick Apoc's ass with.

Originally posted by Soleran
Ok so it's pretty fair to say that range of power is just one of 4 powers you listed, we won't clutter the list anymore fo now.

So MM has shown a great power degree in one aspect of 4, you answered your own piece, MM displaying greater range doesn't nec make him a better Telepath, it simply means he can scan FARTHER then Charles. So it would seem we should be on the same page now, MM can scan farther but being as thats 1 of 4 doesn't make him a stronger telepath overall.

However, he has demonstrated things out of Xavier's reach on basically all of those.

These characters have a lot in common. Both are bald, both shapeshifters, both very powerful but never depicted using their potentials, and both job. As written, MM 10/10. If both to fought to their potential, Apocalypse would take it 5.5/10.

Originally posted by batdude123
Even so, Martian Manhunter has a slew of other powers that he would use to kick Apoc's ass with.

yea so does appoc, (he may have more powers actually)..

Originally posted by batdude123
However, he has demonstrated things out of Xavier's reach on basically all of those.

Oh I see, is this like an I told you so speech? What has he done to demonstrate these skills you profess? Now you have to prove MM can outdo Xavier on all 4 unless your bluffing here.

Better make a new thread, I would hate to see Apoc lose even in a thread about himself when a new character gets discussed😛

Hmmm...

MM:
Vast strength (Well beyond class 100)
Incredibly fast
Intangibility
Shapeshifting (Causes mental strain after hours in said shape)
Telepathy/Mind Control
Able to add mass, density and size by "borrowing" from other object
High level of durability minus weakness to fire

Apoc:
Class 100 strength and beyond (Enough to choke out the Hulk) and able to psionically augment strength further thru extra-dimensional sources.
Very high level of Durability
Psionic Defense Capable of rendering Xavier unconscious
Superior shapeshifting abilities (Through his shape-shifting ability, Apocalypse can give himself virtually any physical power.) He can also remain in said state indefinitely.
Incredible intellect. Genius level in biology and genetics.

While I'm in no way an expert on MM, I think this fight is closer than you guys think. Apoc appears to have superior shapechanging abilities, while MM obviously starts out physically stronger and waaaaaay faster. Using forum rules, which include no jobbing and characters fighting at peak ability, I think MM wins 6, 7/10.

Originally posted by Soleran
Oh I see, is this like an I told you so speech? What has he done to demonstrate these skills you profess? Now you have to prove MM can outdo Xavier on all 4 unless your bluffing here.

Better make a new thread, I would hate to see Apoc lose even in a thread about himself when a new character gets discussed😛

Try mind controlling the entire JLA including Plastic Man who's brain is immune to telepathy. 😐 Also, including Superman who shook of the effects of Despero's telepathy.

Martian Manhunter is so powerful he had to defeat himself in telepathic combat to save the world.

Originally posted by Juntai
Martian Manhunter is so powerful he had to defeat himself in telepathic combat to save the world.

BINGO!!!

Originally posted by batdude123
Try mind controlling the entire JLA including Plastic Man who's brain is immune to telepathy. 😐 Also, including Superman who shook of the effects of Despero's telepathy.

Uh is that PIS, I mean if Fernus couldn't do that to Plastic man but now MM can seems odd, right?

If it took Max years to overcome Superman and MM does it on a moments notice that doesn't sit well with Superman does it?

GL's rings protect them from Mind Control but now MM bypass's all that, weird isn't it?

Despero ravaged MM , now somehow MM flips this to control Superman, kinda odd.

So my point is if thats your best evidence you should ask yourself is it credible looking at the feats of other characters involved, SM, WW (who can resist control by Gods), GL's....................

So you have 2 (thats assuming Charles couldn't do that as well.) 2 more

Originally posted by Soleran
Uh is that PIS, I mean if Fernus couldn't do that to Plastic man but now MM can seems odd, right?

If it took Max years to overcome Superman and MM does it on a moments notice that doesn't sit well with Superman does it?

GL's rings protect them from Mind Control but now MM bypass's all that, weird isn't it?

Despero ravaged MM , now somehow MM flips this to control Superman, kinda odd.

So my point is if thats your best evidence you should ask yourself is it credible looking at the feats of other characters involved, SM, WW (who can resist control by Gods), GL's....................

So you have 2 (thats assuming Charles couldn't do that as well.) 2 more

Oh really??? Since when can WW resist mind controll by gods now?? 😕 Did you just make that one up? Oh you're good. 🙂 However, Despero caught MM off guard. More recently, Martian Manhunter put up a resistence to Despero in a battle. For the GL matter, Kyle didn't have his shield or any kind of construct up for that matter. He was just a sitting duck. It's not really that big of a stretch. Let's be honest: Max Lord<<<<<<<<Martian Manhunter. Also, about the Plastic Man thing. Martian Manhunter had to actually lock away Fernus in his mind so that the fate of the world wouldn't be at stake. He mindcontrolled Fernus away. 🙂 So, there's really nothing that much wrong with the feat. 😉

Originally posted by Soleran
So you have 2 (thats assuming Charles couldn't do that as well.) 2 more

once again read the whole response, my question was rhetorical.

Originally posted by Soleran
once again read the whole response, my question was rhetorical.

Sorry. 😮 Anyway, here he is casting mind illusions on White Martians who are telepathic gods in their own right.

Originally posted by Soleran
once again read the whole response, my question was rhetorical.

Damn, it's not loading. 😠 Hold on.

Prof.X and MM are about equal now that I think about it

Originally posted by batdude123
Sorry. 😮 Anyway, here he is casting mind illusions on White Martians who are telepathic gods in their own right.

Here we are:

http://img250.imageshack.us/my.php?image=martianmanhuntervswhitemartian.jpg

Originally posted by batdude123
Sorry. 😮 Anyway, here he is casting mind illusions on White Martians who are telepathic gods in their own right.

Yeah, as far as the white martians and god like I don't buy so much as the JLA walking through them the way they did in the end. Or how WW fought one tooth and nail when all it had to do was use it's TP godhood as you call it to subdue her.

Ok, there's 3..............one more from the MM respect thread please.

Originally posted by Soleran
Yeah, as far as the white martians and god like I don't buy so much as the JLA walking through them the way they did in the end. Or how WW fought one tooth and nail when all it had to do was use it's TP godhood as you call it to subdue her.

Ok, there's 3..............one more from the MM respect thread please.

1. Are you joking??? 🤨 The White Martians took over the entire planet basically. The JLA by no means just walked right through them. If you get the chance, pick JLA: Terror Incognita. 😉

2. Those are my scans. 😉 They aren't from the respect thread, however I'll see what else I can find.