Okay...here it goes:
Agon:
Originally posted by Agon
I liked the style of your sig, the overall feel to it. The background fitting and the use of a border. The only thing that really seems to be missing is the medieval feel to it. Also, it seems that your use of the sword was just thrown in there to meet the requirements of this duel.
The Pittman:
Originally posted by ThePittman
Good overall medieval feel to the sig, nice use of animation and I like the fact that you used the sword in such a way that it looked like part of the window breaking apart.
What I didn't like is that other than that, no effort was put into the render itself or changing it in any kind of way.
I will have to give this one to The Pittman, for it just feels as if he put a little more time and effort into his sig.
Winner: The Pittman