Superman The Movie Vs Batman Begins

Originally posted by Scarlet315
1.spiderman 2
2.spiderman 3 (yeah, yeah it didnt come out. I call this a strong huntch)
3.X1
4.blade 2
5.superman returns
6.Blade 2

End of Days(yeah yeah i know its not a comic book movie, but damn did it have that comic book feel. Ahnold takes on the devil man!)

only a fanboy, and not a real movie critique, would place superman returns at the top of the "best comic movie" list... 😉

its around 3 not the best but the sequel could depending on what enemy they put in it, so many people didnt go because the villain is the same as the last two movies it follows from.

1. Batman Begins
2. Superman Returns
3. Sin City
4. V for Vendetta
5. Batman Returns
6. Batman 89
7. Superman
8. X Men 2
9. X Men
10. Daredevil

i agree for most except daredevil was worse than hulk, blade 1,2,3 an xmen 3, i'd rather watch any of them than daredevil, although i got every super hero comic movie in my dvd collection

For acting, writing and directing, Batman begins trumps SR... so in general BB was a better movie imo...

This is my top 15 fav superhero movies:

1. Superman Returns (gonna be Spidey 3 next year)
2. Spidey 1
3. V for Vendetta
4. Spidey 2
5. Batman Begins
6. Superman ('78)
7. Batman 1
8. Blade
9. Superman 2
10. Superman 3
11. Hulk
12. Batman 3
13. Batman 2
14. Superman 4
15. Daredevil (IT SUCKED!!!!!!)

Thanks a lot,

later

I forgot the x men movies i like them a lot tho so dont get the idea i dont

thanks,

later

1-Superman 2 - Everyone underestimates this movie, the fight sequence in the city is unlike anything ever seen before or since!

2-Batman (89'Burton) Nicholson was genuis! This is the bar for all future comic movies as I see it. To me, superhero movies, you HAVE to have a villan thats as bad as your hero is good or you got nothing.

3-Superman The Movie - This movie's luthor was more menacing than Returns luthor because they did kill a cop in this movie.

4-Conan The Barbarian

5-Conan The Destroyer

6-Batman Returns - Michelle Phiffer was totally awesome(hot)! I hated the Penguin though but catwoman more than made up for it with perfect scenes/lines/portrayal

7-Spiderman - Awesome new franchise, seemed to take notes from Burtons Batman which is VERY good but villan was kinda weak, I was absolutely amazed how perfect they got spideys movements/mannerisms down perfectly

8-Spiderman 2 - Killer villan better than Green goblin but again weak villan writing/portrayal, if the spidey cartoon fight with doc oc has more fast paced action . . .

9-Batman Begins - The only thing I didnt like was the writing/portrayal of Ras an the fight sequences were too shaky
So again weak villan portrayal by Ras, Scarecrow was good though

10-X-men - Wolverine was awesome, but again another movie that suffered from weak villany

Honorable mention-Blade

If you have well known comic superhero's in a big time movie you have to have villans that will push those heros to their limits an beyond. The limits that have been established in those very comics or you're just not going to do it any justice!
Spiderman an BB both followed the comics material to gold, HFS!
Why didnt superman returns?

yea but he acted like a car salesman throughout, so boring, superman 2's fight scene made me laugh because they sucked, it looks cheesy, extremely dated, you sir are an idiot. period!

Dont know if anyone knew this yet but, they say Gotham in superman returns, on the part where hes saving people all around the world, anyways the black newslady mentions a few places and gotham was one of them (if some of u dont know thats the city of batman)

Batman Begins was better than Superman Returns. No contest.

Originally posted by pr1983
For acting, writing and directing, Batman begins trumps SR... so in general BB was a better movie imo...

Shit. Sorry. Superman The Movie?

Hmm... Superman the movie was pretty damn good... at the time it was awesome...

batman begins

meh, batman begins had most of my favourite actors in it, morgan freeman, christian bale but to say that it's better than superman returns is a twist of the arm for me, because i've watched them both, got BB in my dvd collection but i think they match eachother up from an overall perspective, although my entire family say they'd watch superman more than batman, heck i think its the epic scale of events that catch people eyes more in films, hope the sequel is more epic otherwise it'll seem like it's going backwards rather than forwards!!!

Originally posted by Soss
Though the special effects and storyline were decent in Superman Returns...my favorite comic book movie is still Spider-man and Spider-man 2.

I doubt Superman could top those.

Originally posted by GODOFALL1
Chae El, YOURE WRONG! This is a Superman The Movie vs Batman Begins Thread. Not Spiderman or Superman REturns. 🙂 And Superman the Movie was WAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY better than Batman Begins! NO comparison...........................................at all!!!!!!!!!!!!

Originally posted by Up In Flames
only a fanboy, and not a real movie critique, would place superman returns at the top of the "best comic movie" list... 😉

movei critics gave it an overall of 4 out of 5, it's one of the best no doubt, considering, overall spiderman 2, considered the best, got 4 out of 5 as well, check google, it gives you a reveiws tally at the top, averaging all the worlds top reviewers, www.google.com/search?hl=en&q=superman+returns&meta=

Superman Returns was better of the two fo me....but as for superhero movies in general V for Vendetta tops all for me