Kyle Rayner vs Sentinal(Alan Scott).

Started by DigiMark0073 pages
Originally posted by Sea King
yes i could go for that but it is sentinel in this fight so he wins

Possibly. The version of Kyle was never specified. The "normal" version would be GL, in which case I'd agree with you. But apparently Kyle has the Starheart or somesuch currently, so if we go with current I may have to disagree.

But it's all quite relative...we can't decide without more specific character references.

Originally posted by DigiMark007
Possibly. The version of Kyle was never specified. The "normal" version would be GL, in which case I'd agree with you. But apparently Kyle has the Starheart or somesuch currently, so if we go with current I may have to disagree.

But it's all quite relative...we can't decide without more specific character references.

actually the tread starter said no ion

Originally posted by Darth Martin
No Ion. Should I change Sentinal to regular Alan Scott to make it more even?
Originally posted by Sea King
actually the tread starter said no ion

Ah right.

Fair enough then. 🙂

Is there anything to show why the forum consensus seems to be Alan > Kyle?

Originally posted by Validus
Is there anything to show why the forum consensus seems to be Alan > Kyle?

this is Green Lantern kyle and Sentinal alan so i dont see kyle winnig their

Originally posted by Validus
Is there anything to show why the forum consensus seems to be Alan > Kyle?

lol. No, there isn't. But I like Alan so this forum-wide trend amuses me.

😂

Originally posted by Sea King
this is Green Lantern kyle and Sentinal alan so i dont see kyle winnig their

I'm talking about both as Green Lantern's here. The only thing I've ever heard was that Alan had the experience edge but if that were the case, everyone would say Alan > Hal which isn't the case.

Maybe me and BW should have drafted Alan instead of Kyle

Originally posted by Validus
I'm talking about both as Green Lantern's here. The only thing I've ever heard was that Alan had the experience edge but if that were the case, everyone would say Alan > Hal which isn't the case.

well i dont say alan is greater then hal but i do say they are equals and i can show scans to back that up

Originally posted by newjak86
Maybe me and BW should have drafted Alan instead of Kyle

I'd say yes, except that scans (while they exist) are harder to come by for Alan than Hal and Kyle, because they're more popular (recently at least). A lot of it would have to be taken at your word rather than shown in scans.

Originally posted by Sea King
well i dont say alan is greater then hal but i do say they are equals and i can show scans to back that up

Probably from a single comic. Kyle, Hal, Wally, Superman, and Dr. Fate pretty much sit atop the rest of the DCU as far as actual feats are concerned.

Originally posted by Validus
Probably from a single comic. Kyle, Hal, Wally, Superman, and Dr. Fate pretty much sit atop the rest of the DCU as far as actual feats are concerned.

no not a singal comic either i do have some were around two to three diffrent comics that i can show they are at least equals.

I remember an old silver-age fight where Alan punks him....I don't have scans but I've seen it.

But that's not even canon anymore, since it was before the original Crisis.

not to metion its alan who showed kyle how to use the ring for the most part

Originally posted by Sea King
not to metion its alan who showed kyle how to use the ring for the most part

Moot point. Kyle's well past that now. It's like saying I could beat up Mr. T when he was 4 years old. I could, but right now he'd whup my ass.

Originally posted by Sea King
not to metion its alan who showed kyle how to use the ring for the most part

Sinestro showed Hal how to use his ring but we all know how their fights usually go.

If you want to say Alan and Hal are equals, thats fine. I would agree but I could easily make the case that Kyle is equal to both too. His feats are unsurpassed by anyone, period.

Originally posted by DigiMark007
Moot point. Kyle's well past that now. It's like saying I could beat up Mr. T when he was 4 years old. I could, but right now he'd whup my ass.

sinestro tought hal jordan and hal may have beat him but he always had a hell of a fight on his hands

Originally posted by Validus
Sinestro showed Hal how to use his ring but we all know how their fights usually go.

If you want to say Alan and Hal are equals, thats fine. I would agree but I could easily make the case that Kyle is equal to both too. His feats are unsurpassed by anyone, period.

i never thought kyle was below them as a matter fact i always thought he was al least their equals if not better as gl. if were dealing with sentinal then hes stronger then kyle and if you read the comic were brain wave took controll of sentinal you see were he tells kyle to kill him before its to late. then he gets compleat controll of him and kyle figures out he wants him to kill alan. then brain wave tells kyle that he was not fighting to full abilty cause he did want kyle to kill alan cause that would drive jade crazy with rage aginst kyle.

Yet you still believe that GL Alan Vs GL Kyle has Alan coming out on top. I'm just saying theres nothing to suggest Alan would defeat Kyle if both are just at their Green Lantern power levels and that Alan being better or having more willpower than Kyle is an unfounded opinion.