Originally posted by ESB -1138
He shown it against Jack and Norrington. Just watch the 3 way duel again and you can see that Will is clearly the best. Jack would be able to beat them all but it would be using his wits but it said best sword fighter so that would be Will.
Norrington and Will are equal.
I like Johnny Depp and all, but it's obvious that if it were a fight to the death, he'd eventually lose. Hell, I'd argue Barbossa is the better "sword fighter".
Will completley kicks Jacks ass at sword fighting im sorry lol 😂 but its true..I wish Jack could whoop him but PotC1 and PotC2" shows us that he can fight better than Jack with a sword..He would have beaten him in the first one had Jack not cheated.
His sword got knocked out of his hand in the latest one whilst up on the church roof.
Barbossa is the best imo. He arguably has more experince than any of them and we could see he had the upper hand against Jack in POTC1. Also if he was to fight against Norrington and Will he wouldnt be limited to the rules - he would be more than happy to cheat whereas the others would not. This in itself gives him a significant advantage.
However I havent heard the commentary so my opinion is a bit biased. Whatever the commentary says is canon so there is no point in arguing with it.
Originally posted by LovelyOne
^^ I think Liz would cheat too 😂
Originally posted by Escape81
Norrington and Will are equal.I like Johnny Depp and all, but it's obvious that if it were a fight to the death, he'd eventually lose. Hell, I'd argue Barbossa is the better "sword fighter".
Originally posted by Rampant ox
Barbossa is the best imo. He arguably has more experince than any of them and we could see he had the upper hand against Jack in POTC1. Also if he was to fight against Norrington and Will he wouldnt be limited to the rules - he would be more than happy to cheat whereas the others would not. This in itself gives him a significant advantage.However I havent heard the commentary so my opinion is a bit biased. Whatever the commentary says is canon so there is no point in arguing with it.
Barbossa gained his skill from fighting in actually fights. And who knows how often Barbossa actually fought. Will on the other trained with many different swords for three hours a day.
I wouln'd put Barbossa on Will's level or Norrington's but he is without a doubt better then Jack. After all the screenwriters themselves said Will was the best.
Originally posted by ESB -1138
Barbossa gained his skill from fighting in actually fights. And who knows how often Barbossa actually fought. Will on the other trained with many different swords for three hours a day.I wouln'd put Barbossa on Will's level or Norrington's but he is without a doubt better then Jack. After all the screenwriters themselves said Will was the best.