Was Golum based on Bilbo and Gandalf

Started by Grand_Moff_Gav1 pages
Grand_Moff_Gav Senior Member

Was Golum based on Bilbo and Gandalf

Just I was watching the films and they appeared very similar....or are they family, 馃槀 I know this is more film related than the story but can anyone tell me?

Naib Come and get me!

Originally posted by Grand_Moff_Gav
Well?
You must love trouble, eh? And no to that rhetorical if not ridiculous question. Although I do some resemblance.

搂P0oONY Senior Member

I personally believe that is a possibility. I'll go ask J.R.R...

Devalion Senior Member

Well Gollum certainly has Bilbo's eyes and Gandalfs nose!

Grand_Moff_Gav Senior Member

it seems this thread could well be accurate...

ESB -1138 Sonic Speed

Re: Is Gollum the Illegitimate child of Gandalf and Bilbo?

Originally posted by Grand_Moff_Gav
Well?
Grand_Moff_Gav Senior Member

Originally posted by ESB -1138
Gollum's Brother?

搂P0oONY Senior Member

PoTC 2 was a terrible film btw.

Grand_Moff_Gav Senior Member

I agree

Bardock42 Junior Member
Originally posted by Grand_Moff_Gav
Just I was watching the films and they appeared very similar....or are they family, 馃槀 I know this is more film related than the story but can anyone tell me?

You mean did the people that made the movie decide that it would be a good idea to make Gollum a mix of Gandalf and Bilbo...hmm...nope..no..they didn't.

Beleg没r (Melc贸r毛)

*Shakes head....*