Heavy Hitters!!!! Who can beat the Hulk!!!!!!!

Started by Accel13 pages

Originally posted by Apolloknight
No its not, its not that hard to answer at all, we know his durability is not unlimited, therefore, Limitless strength>>>>Hulks Durability. Don't try to put more words into this because you cant, its simple, if you didn't understand it read it again.

If his anger is unlimited (this has been stated by the Beyonder on panel and Stan Lee) and his durability increase with his anger (we've seen this happen on panel as well), what are we left to conclude?

As for the question at hand, if we're talking about a very pissed-off Savage Hulk, then not many brawlers below Thanos can do it imo.

Originally posted by Apolloknight
1. limitless Strength
2. Does this really matter if one solid blow to Jar/Daze is all you need, but Any High tier brawler can go toe to toe with Hulk, Things is not the fastest Heavy Hitter yet he doesn't seem to have a problem landing blows on the Hulk.
3. This is Savage, plain in simple.
4. doesn't matter, Limitless Strength>>>>Durability.

1. Limitless strength doesn't always equate to victory, especially if your opponent is much stronger than you to begin with,
2. When I said "quick," I was referring to speedblitz speed.
3. Okay.
4. Not if said durability also grows along with said strength.
Originally posted by Apolloknight
And to say anyone Thanos and above can beat Hulk is kinda dumb, err, When has Thanos ever presented limitless Strength, he doesn't have strength feats ya know. I know all his profiles states he has vast amounts and the upper limit is not known, but no where does it say limitless, HMMM.

barker
Originally posted by Grimm22
Stan Lee has said a lot of things 😐

He has lost his mind.

The real creator of Marvel was Jack "Da King" Kirby.


Stan Lee co-created Hulk with Jack Kirby and he wrote the Incredible Hulk King Size Special where the narration referred to Hulk's strength as "limitless."
Originally posted by Apolloknight
Yes Hulk has done some crazy this before, but so has the Gem of Cytorakk, Juggenaut also once possessed Telepathic ability's among other things, that he has of course lost, also, there are many other things Juggernaut is capable of that even he is not fully aware of. Yes Hulks brain has changed but this still is not proof enough that it now can go past 100% capacity, you cant basically, even Galactus has a limit, your not going to see him giving work to LT now.

Hulk's brain doesn't have a 100% capacity. If you believe he does, prove it, as I have proved the opposite to be true.

And a full-powered Galactus has been described as capable of destroying the universe 10X over.

Originally posted by Grimm22
Stan Lee has said a lot of things 😐

He has lost his mind.

The real creator of Marvel was Jack "Da King" Kirby.


Stan Lee co-created Hulk with Jack Kirby and he wrote the Incredible Hulk King Size Special where the narration referred to Hulk's strength as "limitless."

gay hulk, and that isnt milk.... 😐

Originally posted by bigbran
gay hulk, and that isnt milk.... 😐

😆 😆 😆

Originally posted by bigbran
gay hulk, and that isnt milk.... 😐

That is not funny at all it is just sick 😘 😐

Wolverine owns Hulk

Wolverine sucks 😉

Originally posted by Accel
If his anger is unlimited (this has been stated by the Beyonder on panel and Stan Lee) and his durability increase with his anger (we've seen this happen on panel as well), what are we left to conclude?

As for the question at hand, if we're talking about a very pissed-off Savage Hulk, then not many brawlers below Thanos can do it imo.

1. Limitless strength doesn't always equate to victory, especially if your opponent is much stronger than you to begin with,
2. When I said "quick," I was referring to speedblitz speed.
3. Okay.
4. Not if said durability also grows along with said strength.

Juggernauts Strength has been said to be able to shatter planets on panel, also, His fight with the other exemplars was stated to be the greatest fury ever unleashed on earth by the narrator.

Narrator=Writer/Editor>>>Beyonder.

Also, we have shown you an article of Juggernauts Limitless Strength show me Stans, and guess what, when you do, I will still disagree with it since you disagree with the Editors about Juggernaut. See how easy that is!!!!!! You cant make claims for something if you cant prove it, sorry, Stan has just be dismissed.

Also, His Durability does grow with his Strength, but not as fast, I never argued that.

Originally posted by Accel

Hulk's brain doesn't have a 100% capacity. If you believe he does, prove it, as I have proved the opposite to be true.

And a full-powered Galactus has been described as capable of destroying the universe 10X over.

Stan Lee co-created Hulk with Jack Kirby and he wrote the Incredible Hulk King Size Special where the narration referred to Hulk's strength as "limitless."

Also, How does hulks brain not have an 100% capacity................err, do you even know what you just said. And when have you ever proved the opposite to be true, did you read Dalaks post a few pages back, even he had to admit that Hulks anger cannot be Limitless.

You missed my Point, Galactus has a limit, so what if He destroys the universe 10x over, you thing LT is going to care? He has an entire mult-verse to Judge, one universe he could care less about. My point was, everybody has limits on there power, Galactus and down, yes, to even Include the Hulk.

And you missed my point on Thanos also, If Hulk TRULY has unlimited anger Accel, answer me this, how could he ever lose?

I mean stop and think about this question before you reply to this, for if his anger is unlimited, then he has Unlimited Strength, Stamina and Durability.

Who would ever beat a pissed off Hulk in a pure slug-feast? I will answer you my own question........nobody, you said his strength can match Celestials in seconds, so Honestly Accel, who could beat the Hulk if his Anger was TRULY Unlimited, without the use is PIS/CIS?

Originally posted by Apolloknight
Juggernauts Strength has been said to be able to shatter planets on panel, also, His fight with the other exemplars was stated to be the greatest fury ever unleashed on earth by the narrator.

Good for him, although I fail to see the relevance to the topic at hand here.
Originally posted by Apolloknight
Narrotor=Writer/Editor>>>Beyonder.

The Beyonder was written to examine Hulk with his cosmic powers and he saw that Hulk's rage and strength were limitless. You're basically saying that even if it happens on panel, it doesn't matter.
Originally posted by Apolloknight
Also, we have shown you an article of Juggernauts Limitless Strength show me Stans, and guess what, when you do, I will still disagree with it since you disagree with the Editors about Juggernaut. See how easy that is!!!!!! You cant make claims for something if you cant prove it, sorry, Stan has just be dismissed.

That's kind of petty, especially since I excepted what the editors said about Juggernaut's limitless strength.

However, it's not the same, for two very big reasons. Stan Lee co-created the Hulk and I'd say he knows more about his own character than a random group of editors. 😉 Also, those editors stated it was their opinion, meaning it wasn't fact. Their opinion doesn't have complete authority over 30 years of two characters. Now we have several comics (y'know, those books where these writers and editors work on) that state just the opposite several times and not just once in a blue moon.

Originally posted by Apolloknight
Also, His Durability does grow with his Strength, but not as fast, I never argued that.

So his durability is also unlimited.
Originally posted by Apolloknight
Also, How does hulks brain not have an 100% capacity................err, do you even know what you just said. And when have you ever proved the opposite to be true, did you read Dalaks post a few pages back, even he had to admit that Hulks anger cannot be Limitless.

I posted two quotes for you, I believe in the juggernaut vs Hulk thread. I know you saw them since you commented on them and merely dismissed them as hyperbole. BTW, what Dalak says rarely affects my arguments.

As for Stan Lee, it's fair enough that you'd doubt me without evidence, as I have done the same for Juggernaut's strength until someone posted evidence, but since I managed to provide scans and quotes for practically every thing I stated, I figure you'd have at least some faith in my credibility.

Originally posted by Apolloknight
You missed my Point, Galactus has a limit, so what if He destroys the universe 10x over, you thing LT is going to care? He has an entire mult-verse to Judge, one universe he could care less about. My point was, everybody has limits on there power, Galactus and down, yes, to even Include the Hulk.

So you're saying even guys like Juggernaut have limits?
Originally posted by Apolloknight
And you missed my point on Thanos also, If Hulk TRULY has unlimited anger Accel, answer me this, how could he ever lose?

'Cause it's Thanos, the guy who smacks around heralds for fun and holds his own against Sky-Fathers.

Even though he stated he didn't want to fight the Hulk and he never fought the Savage one, his fight with Prof. Hulk at least gives us an idea of his strength advantage in the beginning. Overall, Savage could possibly beat him in pure H2H, but I guess we'll never see it actually happen.

Originally posted by Apolloknight
I mean stop and think about this question before you reply to this, for if his anger is unlimited, then he has Unlimited Strength, Stamina and Durability.

Right. I'm glad you finally understand.
Originally posted by Apolloknight
Who would ever beat a pissed off Hulk in a pure slug-feast? I will answer you my own question........nobody, you said his strength can match Celestials in seconds, so Honestly Accel, who could beat the Hulk if his Anger was TRULY Unlimited, without the use is PIS/CIS?

I said his strength has matched Celestial-level in moments, but that doesn't necessarily mean it's going to happen in each fight.

Depends on how you see it. Is it PIS if Namor knocks him out? Is it PIS if Thanos says he doesn't want to fight Hulk? Frankly, this is why it's not such an easy question to answer, but I'll stick with my original answer for now:

"As for the question at hand, if we're talking about a very pissed-off Savage Hulk, then not many brawlers below Thanos can do it imo."

Originally posted by Accel
Good for him, although I fail to see the relevance to the topic at hand here.

"Greatest Fury ever unleashed on earth" hmmm, isn't hulk on earth???

Originally posted by Accel

The Beyonder [B]was written
to examine Hulk with his cosmic powers and he saw that Hulk's rage and strength were limitless. You're basically saying that even if it happens on panel, it doesn't matter.

That's kind of petty, especially since I excepted what the editors said about Juggernaut's limitless strength.

[/B]

Oh so you accepted Juggernauts limitless strength, I must of missed that, then I apologize.

Originally posted by Accel

So his durability is also unlimited.

Again, How could Thanos beat someone with Unlimited Durability?

Originally posted by Accel

I posted two quotes for you, I believe in the juggernaut vs Hulk thread. I know you saw them since you commented on them and merely dismissed them as hyperbole. BTW, what Dalak says rarely affects my arguments.

What quotes where they again, refresh my memory?

Originally posted by Accel

So you're saying even guys like Juggernaut have limits?

Yes he is limited to what The Cytorakk can give him, and Cytorakk has enough power to trap Galactus in his universe. Don't mis-read this and think i said Juggernaut can take on Galactus, because he cant, I'm just saying, Juggernauts Source of Power>>>>Hulks rage.

Originally posted by Accel

I said his strength [B]has matched Celestial-level in moments, but that doesn't necessarily mean it's going to happen in each fight.

[/B]

So that means in a fight his anger wont go off the scale each time right, awesomeness, rack up a few wins for the Thanos and anyone to Juggernaut.

Originally posted by Accel

Depends on how you see it. Is it PIS if Namor knocks him out? Is it PIS if Thanos says he doesn't want to fight Hulk? Frankly, this is why it's not such an easy question to answer, but I'll stick with my original answer for now:

"As for the question at hand, if we're talking about a very pissed-off Savage Hulk, then not many brawlers below Thanos can do it imo."

I Don't think its PIS that namor knocked him out, but you do, and if you Don't, you should, because You say that Hulks anger is unlimited, when Beyonder only said "He is an Infinity of Strength", I didn't see anger in that comment.

And like I said, the Stan lee comment cannot be taken into consideration and you know it, How would you like it if I said "Man in this one comic, Galactus said Juggernauts Punch could destroy the universe" and didn't provide proof, but stuck by it like white on rice. Wouldn't make much sense with out proof huh?

Originally posted by Apolloknight
Juggernauts Strength has been said to be able to shatter planets on panel, also, His fight with the other exemplars was stated to be the greatest fury ever unleashed on earth by the narrator.

Narrator=Writer/Editor>>>Beyonder.

Also, we have shown you an article of Juggernauts Limitless Strength show me Stans, and guess what, when you do, I will still disagree with it since you disagree with the Editors about Juggernaut. See how easy that is!!!!!! You cant make claims for something if you cant prove it, sorry, Stan has just be dismissed.

Also, His Durability does grow with his Strength, but not as fast, I never argued that.

Beyonder = narrator/writer/editor.

And so what, Hulk's strength has been as well. He and Ironclad shook countless of universes once. And what does fury mean? Not necessarily strength output. The output would have been phenomenal, I'd believe that. But there's more than just Juggernaut.

As for the article, you've shown a vague note that implies that GENERAL current opinion around the HQ believe that his strength is unlimited. There's nothing official or clear cut. Meaning two things:

1: it could change any moment, which has obviously happened before.
2: it could include literally everyone's opinion, from the chief editor to the chief editor's personal secretary.

Now, I'm still open to some undebiable evidence, but so far, all of Juggernaut's power ups appear to be beyond his own will. Sorry. But it's not too late for Marvel to make it official, though. But so does the Hulk for an unlimited increase of durability.

Also, How does hulks brain not have an 100% capacity................err, do you even know what you just said. And when have you ever proved the opposite to be true, did you read Dalaks post a few pages back, even he had to admit that Hulks anger cannot be Limitless.

You missed my Point, Galactus has a limit, so what if He destroys the universe 10x over, you thing LT is going to care? He has an entire mult-verse to Judge, one universe he could care less about. My point was, everybody has limits on there power, Galactus and down, yes, to even Include the Hulk.

And you missed my point on Thanos also, If Hulk TRULY has unlimited anger Accel, answer me this, how could he ever lose?

I mean stop and think about this question before you reply to this, for if his anger is unlimited, then he has Unlimited Strength, Stamina and Durability.

Who would ever beat a pissed off Hulk in a pure slug-feast? I will answer you my own question........nobody, you said his strength can match Celestials in seconds, so Honestly Accel, who could beat the Hulk if his Anger was TRULY Unlimited, without the use is PIS/CIS?

Dalak admitted, if I remember correctly, that his durability may not be increase at the same rate as his strength. I happen to disagree with that, but okay. This stuff is debatable, since it's never been specified. But my theory makes the most logical sense of all.

He may have a 100% capacity, but what if it's so high that it's beyond anything calculable? What if it's so high that literally any feat can be pulled off with the strength that those levels generate? It didn't take the Hulk's 100% to break Onlslaught, eventhough his strength shoot through the roof? And then again, he may not have a 100% capacity. Infinity doesn't have a 100% capacity, so the Hulk's anger may be limitless still.

The Hulk sometimes loses because his anger isn't a tangible power he can use against everyone. His desires, are an entirely different matter, but his anger is something that must be provoked. He's not always provoked to function at peak level(because he can't always immediately deduce how power his foe is), he's not always catching up with something because he may not be given the time, Improving phsyique isn't always enough in a fight etc. In the context of a narrative there's plenty of reason's why Hulk can't always live up to his potential. He may be distracted, he may underestimate someone, he may be possessed, he may struggle with weaknesses(take prof. Hulk's Savage Banner plague, for example), he may be otherwise restrained etc.

The same basic principles go for every other character who's powers are balanced out with certain weaknesses/limitations. Especially for protagonists, who shoulnd't become invincible all of the time. That's why they arranged Hulk's(and others) powerset so that he he has plenty of moments to shine and also certain moments that cause tension, show him defeated or provoke thought. This is, ofcourse, ignoring the fact that there's also the possibility of PIS and CIS, but those lines are sometimes blurred. Yes, even for Juggernaut and Thor. But that's not my point anyway.

And yes, if his strength increases to, say celestial heights, he HAS to increase his durability to keep himself from being torn apart. There is one instance where Hulk's strength increased, but his durability didn't. Post-onslaught. Guess what? His health was detoriating at the time due to the seperation from Bruce, causing his body to function differently. This is a good argument, because it shows that the Hulk's durability needs to increase to keep up with the strength, which, at the time, it didn't. In fact, it went down. He also lost his ability to grow stronger with rage.

And matching celestial heights in terms of strength does not equal victory. Especially if that strength cannot counter all the other powers. But if this were purely a fist fight, then he should be able to hold his own against anyone who's on the same level as him at that moment. Unless ofcourse, that person starts to increase his strength, after which Hulk would have to keep growing. But the funny thing is, the Hulk's strength stops growing when the job is done, but what if the job can never be done? What if his opponent is completely immortal(Like Juggernaut)? Then it would keep increasing until he's won. But since he'll never knock him out, it will keep increasing. And it will keep increasing at a faster rate too.

Ofcourse, this stuff wrapped in that kind of scenario has never happened, and it will likely never happen. But you can't say it can't happen if the Hulk's power set allows for it.

Originally posted by Accel
Good for him, although I fail to see the relevance to the topic at hand here.

The Beyonder [B]was written to examine Hulk with his cosmic powers and he saw that Hulk's rage and strength were limitless. You're basically saying that even if it happens on panel, it doesn't matter.

That's kind of petty, especially since I excepted what the editors said about Juggernaut's limitless strength.

However, it's not the same, for two very big reasons. Stan Lee co-created the Hulk and I'd say he knows more about his own character than a random group of editors. 😉 Also, those editors stated it was their opinion, meaning it wasn't fact. Their opinion doesn't have complete authority over 30 years of two characters. Now we have several comics (y'know, those books where these writers and editors work on) that state just the opposite several times and not just once in a blue moon.

So his durability is also unlimited.

I posted two quotes for you, I believe in the juggernaut vs Hulk thread. I know you saw them since you commented on them and merely dismissed them as hyperbole. BTW, what Dalak says rarely affects my arguments.

As for Stan Lee, it's fair enough that you'd doubt me without evidence, as I have done the same for Juggernaut's strength until someone posted evidence, but since I managed to provide scans and quotes for practically every thing I stated, I figure you'd have at least some faith in my credibility.

So you're saying even guys like Juggernaut have limits?

'Cause it's Thanos, the guy who smacks around heralds for fun and holds his own against Sky-Fathers.

Even though he stated he didn't want to fight the Hulk and he never fought the Savage one, his fight with Prof. Hulk at least gives us an idea of his strength advantage in the beginning. Overall, Savage could possibly beat him in pure H2H, but I guess we'll never see it actually happen.

Right. I'm glad you finally understand.

I said his strength has matched Celestial-level in moments, but that doesn't necessarily mean it's going to happen in each fight.

Depends on how you see it. Is it PIS if Namor knocks him out? Is it PIS if Thanos says he doesn't want to fight Hulk? Frankly, this is why it's not such an easy question to answer, but I'll stick with my original answer for now:

"As for the question at hand, if we're talking about a very pissed-off Savage Hulk, then not many brawlers below Thanos can do it imo." [/B]

so do you mean when a weak thanos owned hulk, and x-man.
you ruined yourself by saying hulk could beat thanos.

Originally posted by bigbran
so do you mean when a weak thanos owned hulk, and x-man.
you ruined yourself by saying hulk could beat thanos.

X-man was jobbing to Thanos and Hulk

hulks strength has never, never reached celestial levels.

Originally posted by bigbran
hulks strength has never, never reached celestial levels.

Okay I was defending X-man not Hulk

Pitt would take savage Hulk, their strength would be matched, Hulk feeds off of his own anger, Pitt feeds off of other peopleSs anger.

That would kick @$$.

holds his own against Sky-Fathers.

Thanos never held his own against sky-fathers. Getting beaten up over and over again isnt "holding his own", it's called stubborn sadomasochistic tendencies.

Pythons also beat Hulk. They are his one true weakness

Originally posted by aliveinboston
Thanos never held his own against sky-fathers. Getting beaten up over and over again isnt "holding his own", it's called stubborn sadomasochistic tendencies.

Then obviously you never saw Thanos against Odin or Tyrant or Galactus, and the fact that although he'd walk out smoking... he'd still be walking away from the best the skyfathers had...

Thanos is a pimp. He was even considered by death to be her mate.

.....

Originally posted by Apolloknight
"Greatest Fury ever unleashed on earth" hmmm, isn't hulk on earth???

It just means they battled harder than Hulk has on when he was on Earth. It's probably right, too. It doesn't really mean the combatants are the strongest around, though.
Originally posted by Apolloknight
Oh so you accepted Juggernauts limitless strength, I must of missed that, then I apologize.

Tis cool.
Originally posted by Apolloknight
Again, How could Thanos beat someone with Unlimited Durability?

If he can knock him out before he reaches the level of durability necessary to stand up to him. Now the question is, is Hulk durable enough in the beginning to take the Titan's blows and can he reach that certain level of durability before Thanos can knock him out?
Originally posted by Apolloknight
What quotes where they again, refresh my memory?

IH #198- “but that does not deter him--for the madder Hulk gets--the stronger Hulk gets-- and as anyone who has ever met the green goliath can tell you—his rage--And his power—are boundless!!"

IH #225- "Unfortunately the Leader has forgotten a well known fact: The madder the Hulk gets, the stronger the Hulk gets! And when it comes to anger the Hulk knows no limits!!"

IH #322:-"Usually his rage makes him infinitely strong--But not this time. He hit a limit… maybe even got a bit weaker!"

So yeah, as stated multiple times by Marvel, Hulk doesn’t have a limit to his anger. Stan Lee’s comment was in relation that his brain just works differently.

Originally posted by Apolloknight
Yes he is limited to what The Cytorakk can give him, and Cytorakk has enough power to trap Galactus in his universe. Don't mis-read this and think i said Juggernaut can take on Galactus, because he cant, I'm just saying, Juggernauts Source of Power>>>>Hulks rage.

I didn't mis-read it as that at all.
Originally posted by Apolloknight
So that means in a fight his anger wont go off the scale each time right, awesomeness, rack up a few wins for the Thanos and anyone to Juggernaut.

Not necessarily, it just depends on bloodlust. His rage can still go off the scales, but it doesn't have to reach "Celestial-level" each time, even when he fights guys like Abomination or Juggernaut.
Originally posted by Apolloknight
I Don't think its PIS that namor knocked him out, but you do, and if you Don't, you should, because You say that Hulks anger is unlimited,

I never screamed PIS at that. Namor's definitely top-tier under water and Hulk's durability obviously didn't go beyond Namor's strength.
Originally posted by Apolloknight
when Beyonder only said "He is an Infinity of Strength", I didn't see anger in that comment.

"You are nothing but raging power personified! An infinity of power with no finite element inside!"

Originally posted by Apolloknight
And like I said, the Stan lee comment cannot be taken into consideration and you know it, How would you like it if I said "Man in this one comic, Galactus said Juggernauts Punch could destroy the universe" and didn't provide proof, but stuck by it like white on rice. Wouldn't make much sense with out proof huh?

That and the whole "Hulk has unlimited anger" statement are hardly comparable in terms of credibility, especially when you have those quotes posted above.

Originally posted by bigbran
so do you mean when a weak thanos owned hulk, and x-man.

What, when he said he didn't want to fight Hulk? No, I'm referring to what he said when he was fighting the Champion:


Originally posted by bigbran
you ruined yourself by saying hulk could beat thanos.

Hulk beating Thanos is pure H2H is not completely out of the realm of possibility. Surfer didn’t do too badly…


http://img505.imageshack.us/img505/5148/decent9xl.jpg


http://img505.imageshack.us/img505/7249/decent16me.jpg


http://img505.imageshack.us/img505/1739/decent21jm.jpg


http://img505.imageshack.us/img505/2320/decent30vl.jpg

Originally posted by bigbran
hulks strength has never, never reached celestial levels.

In IH #242, he tore apart a machine that was designed to withstand attacks from Celestials with his bare hands.

Originally posted by Accel

What, when he said he didn't want to fight Hulk? No, I'm referring to what he said when he was fighting the Champion:

Hulk beating Thanos is pure H2H is not completely out of the realm of possibility. Surfer didn’t do too badly…


http://img505.imageshack.us/img505/5148/decent9xl.jpg


http://img505.imageshack.us/img505/7249/decent16me.jpg


http://img505.imageshack.us/img505/1739/decent21jm.jpg


http://img505.imageshack.us/img505/2320/decent30vl.jpg

In IH #242, he tore apart a machine that was designed to withstand attacks from Celestials with his bare hands.

so you rather use a quote, than an actual fight?
bravo, bravo.

ill agree with you though, surfer didnt do too bad.



and when did surfer fight hulk in h2h?