Snape the half blooded prince umm no

Started by The Phantom4 pages

Originally posted by stormlover
He didn't. sorry. I don't know where my mind is. I just reread the chapter. Slughorn gave both Ron and Harry books. sorry regulas and everyone else.
Why do I vaguely remember it still?

Originally posted by The Phantom
Why do I vaguely remember it still?

I had that feeling too. But I can't seem to find it.

Originally posted by stormlover
I had that feeling too. But I can't seem to find it.
I think Ron wanted to switch books with Harry at some time, but didn't happen.

Originally posted by Lord Tomahawk
there is 2 books that arnt movies yet. before that i call the death star to destroy you game over i win
That was the stupidest thing ever said in KMC history. You officially fail at everything. You should just castrate yourself, commit suicide, and make your journey to hell as painful as possible.
Originally posted by stormlover
so if it was lily's book, how can snape take credit for it. The person who owned the book must have been older than both lily and snape
You also fail.

ok, seriously, this topic needs not exist. Do we have to debate everything. Hey...wait....maybe Harry isn't really Harry, rather his father wearing contacts and regularly drinking some type of potion to make him younger? *sarcast*

1. The book is 50 years old because it's a text book. IT could have been made 50 years ago, and been bought at a later time or stolen or borrowed, or bought from the current potions master.

2. Snape probably just forgot about the book. IT slipped his mind. He was so excited to become the new DADA teacher he simply forgot the book.

3. Snape is the half blood prince. He says the spells are his, and then he says something along the lines of "my old school book" or something like that.

These are forums you are supposed to debate stuff here and if u dont like it leave

Not necessarily debate...

Originally posted by TheKingofKINGS!
That was the stupidest thing ever said in KMC history. You officially fail at everything. You should just castrate yourself, commit suicide, and make your journey to hell as painful as possible. You also fail.

I owned up to my mistake and corrected it. You're the failure!

None of us are failures okay??

Originally posted by d-fly_girl008
None of us are failures okay??

sorry. I was talking to the king of kings. I'm sick and tired of him saying that everyone fails.

Yeah, I know... you just got to ignore it. I mean... you just have to get over it. Seriously... it will only cause fights if you take it to heart.

Originally posted by d-fly_girl008
Yeah, I know... you just got to ignore it. I mean... you just have to get over it. Seriously... it will only cause fights if you take it to heart.

You're right 😮 . Thanx again 😄

Originally posted by Lord Tomahawk
These are forums you are supposed to debate stuff here and if u dont like it leave

There's nothing to debate here, child. We've told you why Snape had the book. You refuse to believe us; I assume you're trying to be Dumb on Purpose, or that you really have never read the books.

Originally posted by Barker
There's nothing to debate here, child. We've told you why Snape had the book. You refuse to believe us; I assume you're trying to be Dumb on Purpose, or that you really have never read the books.
And for that, he fails.
Originally posted by stormlover
I owned up to my mistake and corrected it. You're the failure!
Weather corrected or not, you still failed 😐

Originally posted by TheKingofKINGS!
And for that, he fails. Weather corrected or not, you still failed 😐

Whether, not weather ( talk about making corrections 🙄 )

Originally posted by Lord Tomahawk
These are forums you are supposed to debate stuff here and if u dont like it leave
Yes, this forum is about debating. Or was because there is really nothing to debate about anymore it seems, but as Barker said.
Originally posted by Barker
There's nothing to debate here, child. We've told you why Snape had the book. You refuse to believe us; I assume you're trying to be Dumb on Purpose, or that you really have never read the books.

We need actually debates again...

I agree

Originally posted by The Phantom
Yes, this forum is about debating. Or was because there is really nothing to debate about anymore it seems, but as Barker said.

We need actually debates again...


I meant the topic. There's nothing to debate about Snape "Possibly" being the Half-Blood prince, or about how his book came into his possesion..

Originally posted by Barker
I meant the topic. There's nothing to debate about Snape "Possibly" being the Half-Blood prince, or about how his book came into his possesion..
I was agreeing with you?

I- .. Uh... srug