Cheering in the courtroom is not allowed.

Started by FeceMan1 pages

Cheering in the courtroom is not allowed.

http://msnbc.msn.com/id/14274742/


OLYMPIA, Wash. - A state panel disciplined a Tacoma judge who ordered courtroom cheers for the Super Bowl-bound Seattle Seahawks before issuing a manslaughter sentence.

The state Commission on Judicial Conduct gave the judge an admonishment, the panel's lowest-ranking punishment, in a ruling released Friday.

Pierce County Superior Court Judge Beverly Grant's discipline stems from a Feb. 3 hearing in which she sentenced Steve Keo Teang to 13 1/2 years for manslaughter in the 2005 shooting death of Tino Patricelli, 28.

Before the proceedings, Grant asked about 100 people in court to say "Go Seahawks" before taking their seats. Dissatisfied with the low volume of the response, she repeated the request.

The Seahawks played in the Super Bowl that weekend. Patricelli's stepmother said she was offended in part because the game fell on the anniversary of her stepson's death.

Grant, who was appointed to the bench in 2003, apologized the following Monday. She eventually filed the formal conduct complaint against herself.

"Although my intentions were to defuse the courtroom situation, I realize now the inappropriateness of my opening comments," Grant told the commission.

Grant agreed to review the state's Code of Judicial Conduct and to not repeat her behavior in the future.

"The behavior in the Grant case was well-intentioned, but a misstep," conduct commission director Reiko Callner told The News Tribune of Tacoma. "The conduct did not materially affect her ruling as a judge in the case."

I chuckled.

YYAAAAAAAAAAHHHHHHHHHH....oops

She filed a complaint against herself?

Holy shit, rules and regulations get ridiculous sometimes.

Alliteration not intended.

i would chuckle if it wasnt over the case of someone who was killed, and especially not if the familiy of that person had to witness it all become trivialised in such a manner.

Originally posted by PVS
i would chuckle if it wasnt over the case of someone who was killed, and especially not if the familiy of that person had to witness it all become trivialised in such a manner.

Good call. 👆

I don't know, I think of myself of a person with a rather broad sense of humour, but I didn't find very funny...

Re: Cheering in the courtroom is not allowed.

...a Tacoma judge...ordered courtroom cheers for the Super Bowl-bound Seattle Seahawks before issuing a manslaughter sentence.

* not surprised *

Originally posted by PVS
i would chuckle if it wasnt over the case of someone who was killed, and especially not if the familiy of that person had to witness it all become trivialised in such a manner.

True. And though it would be more humorous in a different context, I would still accept the judge being disciplined - such displays, regardless of type of case they accompany, have no place in a court room.

Originally posted by PVS
i would chuckle if it wasnt over the case of someone who was killed, and especially not if the familiy of that person had to witness it all become trivialised in such a manner.

Way to be a ****ing spoilsport.

sorry to kill all the nonexistant fun.

Originally posted by FeceMan
Way to be a ****ing spoilsport.

He also did that when I laughed about that 11 year old baby getting raped....he jsut has no sense of humour.

no, i actually found that funny. it was that you mentioned his refusal to give you a reach around that i thought crossed the lines of good humor.

That thread ought to be stickied.

Originally posted by PVS
no, i actually found that funny. it was that you mentioned his refusal to give you a reach around that i thought crossed the lines of good humor.

Well, i mean, it's just not cool to refuse that, though. Right? ...Right? I mean..even if you are a baby and stuff..it's just not fair.

In training for CPR on infants, a guy I was working with pointed at the doll's open mouth and commented, "You know, you could...get pleasure off of that."

I sighed. And yelled.

Originally posted by FeceMan
In training for CPR on infants, a guy I was working with pointed at the doll's open mouth and commented, "You know, you could...get pleasure off of that."

I sighed. And yelled.

Haha, that guy seems like fun..you should go clubbing with him or something.

Is cheering allowed when cases are won ?

Originally posted by Bardock42
Well, i mean, it's just not cool to refuse that, though. Right? ...Right? I mean..even if you are a baby and stuff..it's just not fair.

I started wondering how the baby managed to do that...also I am wondering what the hell I just admitted....sick...SICK I SAY.

Originally posted by Bardock42
I started wondering how the baby managed to do that...also I am wondering what the hell I just admitted....sick...SICK I SAY.

I reaized the confusion.....Kram3r

Originally posted by GCG
Is cheering allowed when cases are won ?

I don't think so, no.