Clones to Storm Troopers

Started by Ronch_Jedi8 pages

I think the stromtrooper's helment is cooler than the clone's, by the way we've never sean stromtroopers take off their helments off so we won't know until Ep3

We've heard them speak with different voices though...

a clone isn't exactly 100% the same in every aspect I think

well depends yerss, I don't know anything about cloning so this has no scientific fact, but I think if u clone someone u take over all the physical aspects so I believe voices should be identical unless something altered the physical aspects

(also lemme bring in my that I knowvery lil' of biology (ask yerss 😄))
so if voice has anything to do with mental aspects then I think they could have a different voice cause I think if u clone a person they have a different mind

but aren't the clones in ANH COAC?

and please FM, do pass bio next time 😄

The clones in AOTC are clearly shown as actually being identical. They would sound the same.

Yet we do have that GL quote. Hmm...

what GL quote???? and what if one clone was just having a throat problem that day 😉 ....then he would sound different

As I think I mentioned before, there is a GL quote that seems to confirm that stormtroopers are clones.

oh...but they can't all be.....that would shatter my EU dreams 😄

like said, it can be that the clones in ANH are COAC!

What is COAC???? 😕

Clone of a Clone, but that's just yerssot rambling, really.

oh there's a big surprise 🙄

no! a clone of a clone is not the same as a clone of the original!
the error percentage in a coac is bigger then one in a clone of an original

so the voices can differ if you put both clones next to eachother

uh-huh....for some odd reason that makes sense....but I still think that they eventually turned to humans to fuel the imperial Navy

See? He's just rambling.

Please stop, yerss. There is never ANY need to overcomplicate. Trying to bring real-world science into this to solve this problem is futile.

It doesn't make sense. It is nonsense. We have absolutely no reason to think they would clone clones, and in any case the difference in voices, judging by the perfection of the originals (which makes any attempt to use real-world science in this case as laughable as with anything else in Star Wars) would be minute regardless if the Stormtroop[ers can be considered true clones in any way.

And in any case the clear intimation of the GL quote is that they are cloned just as the Clonetroopers are.

you can't say that there is an error in the explanation!
and I don't mean a spelling error

but there is an error...that's Ush's point...errr I think

I certainly can; you are trying to use real-life science to justify a piece of sci-fi and your implementation is thoroughly flawed.