Bombing of Geonosis

Started by Quinlan_Vos1 pagesPoll

Should the Geonosis arena been bombed?

Bombing of Geonosis

From the book Shatterpoint , Mace realizes that Count Dooku was the shatterpoint of the CIS, but after the start of the war and the months into it, that shatterpoint disappeared. Mace also knows that the Republic could have killed Dooku by bombing Geonosis arena?

My question:

Should Mace Windu have bombed the Geonosis arena and perhaps prevented a devastating war?

Remember: Anakin, Obi-Wan, and Padme were all in that arena. We know from Qui-Gon Jinn that Anakin is the Chosen One.

What would be consequences of the Chosen One not fulfilling his prophecy?

Please give me your input. And vote in the poll.

It was a better military strategy, definitely, but, Jedi =/ Generals.

Yeh I read Shatterpoint too - Mace knew Ani had to survive even if it means lots of jedi be killed. So even though Dooku survives it seems as Mace says at end of book that Ani holds the future of everything

uh-huh

Please use the PT area thread.

Closed.